Live data from Hacker News

Get Running with Couch to 5K

nhs.uk

41–50 of 232 posts

Re: Get Running with Couch to 5K

#41
post #7

Running is better than sitting on the coach. But strength training is better than running. Why you should not be running , by Mark Rippetoe: https://startingstrength.com/article/why-you-should-not-be-r...

That article makes a good argument, but I feel like it misses the potentially more significant issue that running is an actively bad choice of exercise for a lot of people even if they want to focus on cardio. It's harder on the body than a lot of other cardio exercises, particularly for the target audience of things like "couch to 5k". It's definitely better for you than sitting on the couch, but only if you stick w…

Running has the advantage of cost and simplicity. A pair of running shoes and a very simple free programme like couch to 5k and you're set.

The only exercise I can think of with a lower barrier to entry is walking. Every able-bodied person knows how to run, even if they can't go very fast or far.

Strength training has a higher barrier to entry - weight training requires a gym membership or your own weight room, and you have to learn to perform specific movements correctly and safely, which requires research or paying a personal trainer. Bodyweight strength training also requires learning many not necessarily intuitive movements. Other forms of cardio also usually require an investment in expensive equipment (eg. cycling) or a membership (eg. swimming).

Running isn't recommended to sedentary people because it's an optimal exercise - it's suggested because anyone can pick it up with minimal cost and learning. And it's more time-efficient than walking.

Re: Get Running with Couch to 5K

#44

I did this about four years ago. I hated it. Even running with my collie or listening to audio books didn't help. It just felt like a miserable chore, every time I put on my running shoes. In the end I just quit. Now I hike every weekend, at least 10 miles, which lets me go out with family and friends. I also do various martial arts with my son, which as a shared activity is so much more enjoyable. The only time I'll…

Did you get all the way through the program? Did you have good quality running shoes? I remember it being miserable at the start, but after I finished the program (and was going beyond 5k up to around 12k) it started feeling amazing. It was really strange. It went from painful to just plain addictive!

But then Canadian winters intervened and I got out of the habit and never got back to it again. Since then I’ve had a pretty bad ankle injury (at work, not from working out) and I miss running so much!

Re: Get Running with Couch to 5K

#46
Is there a cycling equivalent Couch to 5k app?

Given the impact running has on the joints, it would be great to do a program like this with a bike instead.

(Other than Peloton which obviously has a high entry cost and even their app-only experience is pretty expensive for what it is)

Re: Get Running with Couch to 5K

#48
Personally, I think aren't many better return on investment activities than spending half an hour every day on a morning jog.

You can run more than that but I think half an hour steady state easy run each morning gives you 80% of results. If you love running (I do), knock yourself out. But that half an hour is enough to do wonders to your health over long periods of time with minimum chance for negative consequences. By easy run I mean one when nothing aches and you can converse easily throughout the run.

I think a lot of people go hard on it and overdo it and then get injured or stop it for other reasons. It is better to make those runs easy and enjoyable so that you can keep running daily forever.

I have also started 4/20 intermittent fasting 3 months ago and keto a month ago and I can tell you, I have never felt better. And this even when I do 10k run in the morning on an empty stomach after 18h of not eating anything.

Re: Get Running with Couch to 5K

#49

Starting running has been one of the best things I've done for myself. It's one of the best ways to explore the world, and I've seen so many interesting things while running. I started in my mid-20s with couch-to-5k. I'd never run more than a mile in my life. It took me a couple attempts to get through the program, but now I've been running pretty consistently for years. I've had a streak of running every day for ove…

Yep, good advice re: taking it slow.

It’s advisable to do some strength training with any running program to help minimise injuries.

Re: Get Running with Couch to 5K

#50
post #46

Is there a cycling equivalent Couch to 5k app? Given the impact running has on the joints, it would be great to do a program like this with a bike instead. (Other than Peloton which obviously has a high entry cost and even their app-only experience is pretty expensive for what it is)

Get a bike trainer - wheel-on trainers are cheaper and use Zwift. If you keep with it you can upgrade later to something nicer or ride your bike outside.
Post reply on HN