Live data from Hacker News

Gripes with RSS after one week

blog.jez.io

21–30 of 99 posts

Re: Gripes with RSS after one week

#21

This article seems to imply that RSS users need to manually locate the RSS feeds. In all the RSS clients I've used, I just add the site by the main URL and it automatically finds the RSS feed if there is one, and this almost always works.

Agree. I use NetNewsWire and always paste in the main URL. Hunting down the rss link is not a thing.

Re: Gripes with RSS after one week

#22
I like Inoreader[0]. The web app is plenty snappy for me, and supports basic vim nav keys, which is a lovely plus. The free plan's 150 feeds are sufficient for my use case. The mobile app also performs well. Mostly it just gets out of my way, which is all I really want.

[0] https://www.inoreader.com

Re: Gripes with RSS after one week

#24
Welcome to the RSS club. Many issues you have noticed are a result of social media. Sites removed RSS after they wanted to push you to Facebook/other.

You may need RSS-bridge (GitHub) as middleware.

I use Yet Another RSS Reader (yarr, also on GitHub), which has very good mobile browser support.

I self host both in my home K8s cluster behind GitHub auth.

Re: Gripes with RSS after one week

#25

This article seems to imply that RSS users need to manually locate the RSS feeds. In all the RSS clients I've used, I just add the site by the main URL and it automatically finds the RSS feed if there is one, and this almost always works.

Ditto, that’s what Feedly does as well

Additionally, the social features the OP mentions are helpful in determining which RSS feed is the right one since some sites have multiple.

Re: Gripes with RSS after one week

#26

This article seems to imply that RSS users need to manually locate the RSS feeds. In all the RSS clients I've used, I just add the site by the main URL and it automatically finds the RSS feed if there is one, and this almost always works.

Agree. I use NetNewsWire and always paste in the main URL. Hunting down the rss link is not a thing.

Two things happened in my first week:

- Using the iOS Safari share button to “Open in NetNewsWire” would silently fail if the blog didn’t have a feed. I went looking for my feeds later and they were missing. I tried a few more times before realizing, “oh, there’s just no feed.”

- Some sites I found had multiple feed links (one per kind of post: long post, short fragments, photo posts). NetNewsWire would always pick the first link in the page, disregarding all others, and not telling me that the page had multiple.

We can say “discovery is not a problem” but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask for it to be better. Half the value proposition of sites like Substack is making it dead simple for readers to understand how they can subscribe.

As someone who had never used RSS before and didn’t know how to expect RSS to work, it was the problem that grated me the most. If discovery isn’t seamless, only the people determined to use RSS will stick with it after their friends pester them to try it out.

Post reply on HN