Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 138 posts

Re: Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

#21
I've used the Collections[1] feature in Edge for this. It essentially acts as a one level deep folder where you can store links and text notes related to a subject. It also has built-in support for sharing.

Disclaimer: I work at Microsoft, but not in Edge.

[1]: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/organize-...

Re: Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

#24
for bookmarking articles, you have https://getpocket.com/ and https://www.instapaper.com/

"Social bookmarking" started with deli.co.us and has largely been subsumed by reddit.

Beyond some level of complexity, Evernote, Obsidian, Notion, etc become bookmarking tools

...but the ultimate place to find the bookmark managers are in the Chrome and Firefox extension stores:

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/extensions/category...

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/search/bookmark?_category...

There doesn't seem to be any money at all in this space, and any really groundbreaking innovation will be folded in by the browser vendors, so I don't expect there to be much more thwn what's already here.

Re: Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

#25
Not exactly “reinventing” bookmarks. But I’ve been working on a micro SaaS[0] to send interesting articles, newsletters and RSS to Kindle. And it kinda “forces” me to actually read those articles, and not just send them into oblivion.

If you’re developing a reading habit in 2023, give it a try.

[0]: https://ktool.io

Re: Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

#26
post #21

I've used the Collections[1] feature in Edge for this. It essentially acts as a one level deep folder where you can store links and text notes related to a subject. It also has built-in support for sharing. Disclaimer: I work at Microsoft, but not in Edge. [1]: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/organize-...

I like Collections, it's a good concept, I'd love to have something that I can use across devices, and share a collection with people, would be kewl to have it integrated with "awesome list" concept from GitHub.

Re: Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

#28
Shiori is a self-hosted bookmark manager that uses tags and it's what I use now. https://github.com/go-shiori/shiori

I've been strongly preferring methods that let me tag items and have a good search - either in addition to or instead of putting them in a folder. If I don't like the "taxonomy" I can just add more tags, instead of constantly trying to figure out the one folder where everything should go.

I can share by creating an additional visitor user, or use the import/export commands. I hope those get built into the UI sometime, but I rarely share more than a single bookmark at a time.

It is an extra step to copy/paste links into Shiori versus browser built-in features, but I prefer not to trust or rely on browsers for my bookmarks unless at work. Seems like everyone wants sync those to accounts without my explicit consent.

Re: Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

#29
Pocket, Collections and reading list fit this description. Really though, it’s just not the way many people think. We don’t navigate rigid taxonomies in order to remember things. Given an excess of available information, a loose semantic connection to a given website is all you really need to know how to get back there (or at least to find similar information again via another search) at a later date.

Also - make use of your address bar’s search functionality. Bookmarking as implemented is still useful.

Seems like something a librarian might enjoy though heh.

Re: Ask HN: Why haven't bookmarks been re-invented?

#30
post #15

The need has been mostly eliminated for many people with the ability to search.

Yea, that is true for sure, like it's so easy to Google Search, but often times I find something related to let's say "data versioning" that might be something like "slowly changing dimensions" but and they're both 'related' but I can't for the life of me remember that they are related 3 months after when I go back to look at it.
Post reply on HN