Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–49 of 49 posts

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#41

Post by veidr »

mgualt wrote: post #40
veidr wrote: post #39

Don't use any 'blogging platform'. Use a static blogging system. The best one currently is probably Octopress[1] which is based on Jekyll[2]. But you could roll your own, and it would still be much better than blogger, wordpress, walmart.com, google+, facebook, tubmlr, etc. Such systems just render your conveniently created post content into a static HTML website than can be published on various free systems (github…

re: comments, I strongly disagree that they are handled "superbly". For many important blogs, the comments are central to the whole endeavour. Why on earth would you cede control of your comments to disqus? Why do you keep your content and your comments separate? Will disqus be around in 2112? This is what I mean when I say that a "static blog system" is not a blog system at all. It is a partially thought-out solutio…

I guess that's a good point if comments are truly important to you. Which they perhaps are, for a tiny minority of blogs.

(I personally don't find comments important at all, and even take advantage of the various browser extensions[1] to hide them on various sites that do have them.)

[1]: e.g. http://stevenf.com/pages/shutup.css.html

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#42

Post by mgualt »

veidr wrote: post #41
mgualt wrote: post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

re: comments, I strongly disagree that they are handled "superbly". For many important blogs, the comments are central to the whole endeavour. Why on earth would you cede control of your comments to disqus? Why do you keep your content and your comments separate? Will disqus be around in 2112? This is what I mean when I say that a "static blog system" is not a blog system at all. It is a partially thought-out solutio…

I guess that's a good point if comments are truly important to you. Which they perhaps are, for a tiny minority of blogs. (I personally don't find comments important at all, and even take advantage of the various browser extensions[1] to hide them on various sites that do have them.) [1]: e.g. http://stevenf.com/pages/shutup.css.html

I claim that comments are integral to the activity of blogging. In fact, most bloggers are chomping at the bit to get more comments, often they will do anything to get more comments, and not necessarily because there's a financial incentive.

If you look at the best blogs, I mean top blogs in their niche such as

http://www.thesartorialist.com/

http://girishshambu.blogspot.com/

http://www.freakonomics.com/blog/

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/

http://terrytao.wordpress.com/

you will see that they are comment heavy. In fact there are very interesting discussions in the comments.

You may think comments are "unimportant" for most blogs, but that is not up to you, it is up to the blogger, and I guarantee that blogger would rather have some comments. And it might help to have a half-decent comment system.

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#43

Post by veidr »

mgualt wrote: post #42
veidr wrote: post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess that's a good point if comments are truly important to you. Which they perhaps are, for a tiny minority of blogs. (I personally don't find comments important at all, and even take advantage of the various browser extensions[1] to hide them on various sites that do have them.) [1]: e.g. http://stevenf.com/pages/shutup.css.html

I claim that comments are integral to the activity of blogging. In fact, most bloggers are chomping at the bit to get more comments, often they will do anything to get more comments, and not necessarily because there's a financial incentive. If you look at the best blogs, I mean top blogs in their niche such as http://www.thesartorialist.com/ http://girishshambu.blogspot.com/ http://www.freakonomics.com/blog/ http://…

I hear you, and I more or less understand the arguments for your position, but I don't agree.

I personally am not much of a blogger, so my own proclivities as a blog writer ('fuck no I don't allow comments on any blog for which I am responsible for picking up the dogshit and spam') aren't too relevant. But many of the blogs I find most valuable do not feature comments, or if they do, they are 99.9% what you'd expect: utterly worthless, time-wasting digital turds.

I think the whole comment thing is misguided. If you really had something worthwhile to say, why on earth would you entrust that to whatever crap-ass 'blogging platform' that blogger in question happened to be using at the moment?

Say it somewhere that you control, and link it. That's how the web works.

Of course, I have seen worthwhile comments (especially on blogs where the author takes the time/effort to aggressively police them). But that's far and away the exception, and not the rule.

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#44

Post by colmmacc »

rmccue wrote: post #23
jacobwg wrote: post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're going to have security holes with every piece of software, though it is true some software is more secure than others. I personally view having security updates as a plus - it shows that the WordPress team (open source community) supports their software. The fact that WordPress is running on 70 million plus websites [1], about 15% of the web [2], means that if a security hole is found, it will be fixed, and it…

In addition, WordPress has a built-in updater, so it's incredibly easy to update, unlike many other platforms which require reuploading or obscure update steps.

Doesn't WordPress' built-in updater require write permissions to the PHP files? That's considered an insecure configuration by many.

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#45

Post by iworkforthem »

The best blogging platform is the one you actually use.

Pick any of the free platform WP, posterous, tumblr, etc. Most of these tools are inter-portable. It really does not matter, the one thing that really matter is the blogging platform that you actually use.

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#46

Post by glimcat »

veidr wrote: post #43
mgualt wrote: post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I claim that comments are integral to the activity of blogging. In fact, most bloggers are chomping at the bit to get more comments, often they will do anything to get more comments, and not necessarily because there's a financial incentive. If you look at the best blogs, I mean top blogs in their niche such as http://www.thesartorialist.com/ http://girishshambu.blogspot.com/ http://www.freakonomics.com/blog/ http://…

I hear you, and I more or less understand the arguments for your position, but I don't agree. I personally am not much of a blogger, so my own proclivities as a blog writer ('fuck no I don't allow comments on any blog for which I am responsible for picking up the dogshit and spam') aren't too relevant. But many of the blogs I find most valuable do not feature comments, or if they do, they are 99.9% what you'd expect:…

Rather than a comments system, I'd prefer something which polls around for copies of the link to see if it turns up on HN or whatever, then includes those. Free moderation, better validation.

Comments can be important if you're trying to build a community or what have you and want people to stay on site longer. But most people use aggregators of one stripe or another, whether RSS or a link site or Facebook.

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#47

Post by phzbOx »

tghw wrote: post #34
phzbOx wrote: post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't agree with wordpress. Wordpress is like a middle-ground with 'lots of features' vs 'easy to use for no tech people'. If you want something really simple to get started, tumblr rocks (You'll have something running in minutes). If you want to hack your blog with lots of custom features, just pick whatever blogging library in your favorite language.

My mother, who refers to her Firefox browser as "the Mozilla" uses Wordpress to maintain her neighborhood association's website. Aside from poorly formatted PDFs she sometimes has me upload, she has no problems using it. I looked at using Tumblr when we were getting her set up, but it did not have enough functionality for what they needed.

Yeah, exactly. It's good for mothers and no tech people. But for hackers, I'd use something else.

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#48

Post by mgualt »

veidr wrote: post #43
mgualt wrote: post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I claim that comments are integral to the activity of blogging. In fact, most bloggers are chomping at the bit to get more comments, often they will do anything to get more comments, and not necessarily because there's a financial incentive. If you look at the best blogs, I mean top blogs in their niche such as http://www.thesartorialist.com/ http://girishshambu.blogspot.com/ http://www.freakonomics.com/blog/ http://…

I hear you, and I more or less understand the arguments for your position, but I don't agree. I personally am not much of a blogger, so my own proclivities as a blog writer ('fuck no I don't allow comments on any blog for which I am responsible for picking up the dogshit and spam') aren't too relevant. But many of the blogs I find most valuable do not feature comments, or if they do, they are 99.9% what you'd expect:…

The fact that you don't allow comments because of "dogshit" and "spam" means that your comments system is broken. That's like saying "I don't do email because of dogshit and spam". Spam is manageable in email, so the fact that it's out of control in comments means that noone has thought through a proper comments system.

When you say "Say it somewhere that you control, and link it. That's how the web works." I understand where you're coming from, but this is simply not true. Wanting something to be true doesn't make it so. The web is not made of a collection of interlinked static HTML files. But the root of your complaint, that by commenting on someone's blog you give away your worthwhile thoughts, is also a failure of the bad comment system.

Comments should work a lot more like email does. Imagine if each blog entry had an email address (or sub-address of the blog's email address) and sending a "comment" was really sending an email to that address. The comment box below the blog entry is really a small email composing window which sends the comment to the blog. And it can also send it to your own email address (as a cc for the purposes of the thought experiment). Then it would be in your email archive and not lost, but you would still be contributing to the discussion happening at the blog. A further benefit of this is that the spam filter for the email address would function for comments on a blog. Why reinvent the wheel? /end example.

I have come to this issue from the experience of working with bloggers with quite long-running substantial blogs on Wordpress or Blogger. They have a huge laundry list of complaints and annoyances with the software but I cannot in good faith recommend a jekyll-octopress solution or a wikified solution, or a "static--html" solution etc. These "solutions" are poorly thought out and would represent a severe reduction in functionality for the sake of "that's how it should be done". It is the result of developers who look at a hard problem (how to best implement all these required features) and decide to get rid of the problem by disparaging the features or the requesters themselves.

Re: Ask HN: Best blogging platform?

#49

Post by bradleyland »

The blogging platform you choose will be as much about you as it is the software.

* Are you a developer?

* How comfortable are you with the command line?

* Do you intend to display a lot of media on your blog?

* Do you intend to display code examples on your blog?

There is no "best" tool in any parlance. The tool you choose will have a lot to do with your preferences.

WordPress: Lots of plug-ins available; common, thus easy to get assistance for; supports a wide variety of blog types; requires diligent attention to security patches and performance tweaking (caching).

Hosted platform (like Tumblr): Zero maintenance; great community; easy to apply themes.

Static site generator (like Jekyll/Octopress): Very hackable; provides some level of street cred for devs; extremely minimal hosting requirements; easy to use your favorite flavor of markup (HTML, ERb, HAML, Markdown, Textile, you name it).

Post reply on HN