Live data from Hacker News

Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

newarab.com

31–40 of 84 posts

Re: Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

#31
post #2

And yet muslim people on facebook say that hijab is by free will..

Is this an example of a dog whistle? Unspecified "Muslim people on Facebook" say something you are almost certain to disagree with. No examples, no nuance, just a call to racism.

[deleted]

Re: Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

#32
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Funny thing is, as a practicing muslim - there is no compulsion in religion (direct quote from the Qur'an). Iran literally is using the ignorance of the populace to push their own means of controlling the masses.

What are some examples of muslim majority countries that allow women to not wear one?

currently in morocco. I see plenty of muslim women without headscarves.

Re: Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

#33
post #14

I feel proud as a human to see these brave women standing up for their rights and wish them and their fellow countrypeople all of the success with no bloodshed. It's time we move out of the age of religious compulsion on all fronts.

Funny thing is, as a practicing muslim - there is no compulsion in religion (direct quote from the Qur'an). Iran literally is using the ignorance of the populace to push their own means of controlling the masses.

(My dad’s grandfather was an imam.) That means that you can’t compel people to convert to Islam: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Baqara_256. That does not mean you can’t have binding religious law Muslims are required to follow.

That being said, the religious requirement is modest dress. Some traditions interpret that to require covering the hair or face. Other traditions do not. Hijab was uncommon in Bangladesh when my parents were growing up, but is increasingly common today due to growing cultural influence from middle eastern schools of Islam. That said, it’s worth noting that Islam is not like Protestant Christianity where lay people are supposed to interpret the meaning for themselves. Where relevant Islamic experts have spoken you’re supposed to defer to their interpretation.

Re: Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

#35
post #2

And yet muslim people on facebook say that hijab is by free will..

Those are almost universally people living in secular states or more moderate muslim ones.

Muslim people living in places with the freedom to choose generally consider it a choice whereas those living in places without that freedom do not or will not admit to such a belief.

Re: Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

#36
post #26
post #2

And yet muslim people on facebook say that hijab is by free will..

There are many muslim people who live in places where that is true

And indeed a few who live in places where governments [propose to] intervene to prevent them from wearing items of clothing associated with some Muslims' ideas of modesty...

Re: Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

#38

I feel proud as a human to see these brave women standing up for their rights and wish them and their fellow countrypeople all of the success with no bloodshed. It's time we move out of the age of religious compulsion on all fronts.

When we encourage people to protest their govt, we endanger their lives while being risk free of our own.

I fear that many of the people who have encouraged these protests are still in the shadows smiling everytime someone dies.

Alinejad is one of them.

Re: Iranian women compete at chess tournament without hijab: media reports

#40
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Funny thing is, as a practicing muslim - there is no compulsion in religion (direct quote from the Qur'an). Iran literally is using the ignorance of the populace to push their own means of controlling the masses.

What are some examples of muslim majority countries that allow women to not wear one?

It's mandatory in two countries by my count, and optional in all the rest.
Post reply on HN