Live data from Hacker News

Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

bath.ac.uk

21–30 of 161 posts

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#21
post #9

Do people still use social media that much?

You're asking this question on a social media site...

I disagree that this is a social media, I don't even look at the names of those who leave comments or those I reply to. It's like I'm reading and talking to the hivemind.

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#22
post #19

Quit Twitter about 6 years ago because of related issues. Checked out Mastodon, but apart from the distributed aspect it just seems like more of the same, as in an evolution upon the experience of watching TV, in the internet era. I've been quite happy without it since.

We followed a similar path and my experience was mostly the same. I wanted the fediverse to be a positive social thing in my life, I gave it a few years but in practice it felt sadly similar. Reading Amusing Ourselves to Death over the holiday helped me understand my relationship to infotainment a little better. (And I'm conflicted about this site too honestly...)

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#23

I am reading Antifragile by Nassim Taleb, and one of his points is that much of invention happens either out of necessity or outside of structure vs traditional R&D / Academia. I was wondering how much social media filling in all spare time keeps people from tinkering and inventing and making progress. Though, I suspect the tinkers are still spending a lot of time tinkering - and only the people who have nothing bett…

There is a line of research according to which social media create addiction [0]. When we are addicted to social media, we have less and less time for tinkering and pushing the envelope, because a sizeable part of our time is claimed by such media.

[0] Griffiths, M. D. (2012). Facebook addiction: Concerns, criticism, and recommendations: A response to Andreassen and colleagues. Psychological Reports, 110, 518–520. https://doi.org/10.2466/01.07.18.PR0.110.2.518-520

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#24
Actually being creative requires work, a lot of it, and the people who are very creative think the work is fun or have accepted it. Best to get into a regular groove of doing your creative work on a predictable schedule.

The opposite of being bored is cultivating your interests, treating them like a garden that takes work but grows over time into a variety of wonderful things.

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#25
It's certainly a way to waste time, but social media is also where I've found a lot of creative partners to work on side projects with, and it's where I've found a lot of inspiration too when looking at people's art, microfiction, etc. So I feel like for me it's probably at least net neutral when I use it properly instead of just doomscrolling.

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#26
post #24

Actually being creative requires work, a lot of it, and the people who are very creative think the work is fun or have accepted it. Best to get into a regular groove of doing your creative work on a predictable schedule. The opposite of being bored is cultivating your interests, treating them like a garden that takes work but grows over time into a variety of wonderful things.

Sounds like something to overcome boredom. Think how much free time they'd have without all that creative work.

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#27
There's a brazillian song called Tédio (Boredom) that was popular in the 80's. It talks about not withstanding boredom inside home, while life goes on out there. It's curious how the depicted feeling is so unrelatable today.

I think boredom is a real force that pushes ourselves to the edge, to hopefully make a change in life, like going out to see real people.

Social media creates this cozy, safe place to keep your mind occupied, letting life pass without realizing it.

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#28
post #20
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're asking this question on a social media site...

I kind of object to that use of the term, when social media was coined it clearly did not apply to pseudonymous forum sites.

From what I can tell from a brief googling, the term "social media" was coined (or at least an early documented use was) by an AOL executive in 1997. I think that refutes your assertion. AOL usernames tended to be pretty pseudonymous.

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#29
post #6

I did not read the study, but the finding seems trivial and limited at the same time: Anything you do to alleviate or prevent boredom that is not creative can be said to 'prevent reaping creative rewards' of boredom. Not just social media (or any media consumption, really) but also sports or calling a friend or helping in a soup kitchen. If you didn't do it, you'd feel boredom, and might pick up something creative in…

This is no doubt true but smart phones basically give you the option to never be bored, and get instant gratification whenever you feel like it. I don’t think it is limited to social media but I imagine there are pretty profound consequences to that.

It is a self regulating problem, bored people create entertainment until there are no other bored people left. Modern tech makes that process more efficient so you have less bored people, I don't see why that is a problem.

Re: Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom

#30
post #19

Quit Twitter about 6 years ago because of related issues. Checked out Mastodon, but apart from the distributed aspect it just seems like more of the same, as in an evolution upon the experience of watching TV, in the internet era. I've been quite happy without it since.

Yet here you are on HN ;)
Post reply on HN