Live data from Hacker News

Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

filmcolossus.com

31–40 of 157 posts

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#31
post #5

Ugh- I thought that when it said spoilers ahead, it would be just the movie being reviewed in the article, which I don’t plan on seeing. Then there were spoilers for other movies (Get Out) that I intend to watch sometime.

Get Out was released 5 years ago. I think if you haven't seen it by now that's on you. Also, Darth Vader is Luke's father, Snape kills Dumbledore, and Bruce Willis is dead the whole movie.

Fortunately Dobby lived to be a grandfather, right?

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#33
post #16

Glass Onion takes the well-worn detective genre and creates some genuinely surprising moments by "cheating" a little with what it shows the audience. This article says it should have played it straight. I think that would have made for a more standard, boring movie. But whatever, that's just opinion. But I think it is silly to call it bad writing. Bad implies that the writer didn't have command of their craft. It is…

Well said. The author is basically complaining that their steak dinner was the worst pizza they’ve ever had.

Except that this was not a steak dinner, not even close. It was a microwave pizza with ananas served in “Italian” restaurant.

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#34

I’m geniunely wondering what the audience is supposed to get from all the 2020 references (Covid, Among Us, Zoom, Twitch), and the barrage of celebrity name-drops. I feel like the film was written for some specific Twitter subculture Rian Johnson is a part of, and maybe they find all the references hilarious. The mystery is dull, the dialogue obnoxious, the jokes unfunny, and the camera has that patented ugly digital…

Pretty sure they're supposed to get that it takes place in 2020

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#35

Is this here because Miles Bron is an anagram for Elon is Mr B? "It’s practically a hit piece on Elon Musk" yeah duh, author must be a real smart one. Don't usually see movie reviews here otherwise. I thought it was pretty good, quite funny at times, fun mystery. I liked first one better but by no means was it bad.

The character has an obsession with repeating a single letter in his company names/products and big sources of changing the world are rockets, cars, and a news site. He also is clearly into crypto (if you look at the background).

It's not a far leap.

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#36

We are seriously in the dark ages of writing right now. It’s not that good books, movies and tv shows aren’t being made, but most of the top tier a list stuff is just astoundingly awful and amateurish. It’s like these industries are trying to make hot garbage now and only occasionally goof up and accidentally end up with a good story.

The problem's that all these big franchise movies can be terrible but still set new ticket sales records. Audiences aren't showing up to watch the new JJ Abrams or Rian Johnson movie, they're showing up to see the new Star Wars movie. Even if it gets bad reviews everybody still wants to see what happens next with Luke and the gang. Then movie pulls in record ticket sales and the studio execs think that means it's a success so they reward the same writers and directors with more movie contracts.

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#37

[spoiler warning] Just watched the movie yesterday evening and I was also quite disappointed, some of the choices did seem cheap, the twin, the book stopping the bullet, the "punishment" of Miles by the destruction of the Mona Lisa. I think that the movie had some potential, but after the twin reveal everything started going south. Edit: added warning

When the twin destroyed that painting, she became the villain of the movie.

Not the one who paid off a government to take a national treasure, then recklessly bypassed the security controls for their own amusement?

Or launch an unsafe product for the general public?

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#39

Glass Onion takes the well-worn detective genre and creates some genuinely surprising moments by "cheating" a little with what it shows the audience. This article says it should have played it straight. I think that would have made for a more standard, boring movie. But whatever, that's just opinion. But I think it is silly to call it bad writing. Bad implies that the writer didn't have command of their craft. It is…

[deleted]

Re: Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery – Bad Writing

#40

Is this here because Miles Bron is an anagram for Elon is Mr B? "It’s practically a hit piece on Elon Musk" yeah duh, author must be a real smart one. Don't usually see movie reviews here otherwise. I thought it was pretty good, quite funny at times, fun mystery. I liked first one better but by no means was it bad.

I admit that I have also wondered whether there is any allusion to Elon, mainly because he is a notorious eccentric CEO.

Nevertheless, I have been amused by this movie much more than I assume that most of its viewers have been, because Miles Bron, more than resembling what I know about Elon, had an uncanny resemblance to the CEO of a startup where I have worked some years ago.

The resemblance was complete, in behavior, in speech, in the dyslexic words invented continuously, in the content of the fax messages with product feature suggestions (though my CEO used e-mail, not fax).

So I wonder how many such CEOs exist and whether the script writer has completely made up the Miles Bron character or he has indeed used a real-life CEO as inspiration.

Post reply on HN