Live data from Hacker News

Moving the Ctrl Key

emacswiki.org

91–100 of 121 posts

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#91
I have done this for years, specifically because of using Emacs, and now get frustrated now when on a non-mapped keyboard. :) It works out good for CUA bindings for other applications also.

However, since I am left-handed, the experience might be a little different for me, since I bias towards the left for all modification keys (that includes the Alt key.) The idea of having those keys comfortably near the thumb is interesting though, as some have mentioned, like having a trackpoint so close by when typing (I also remap the top buttons to favor me using my left hand more.)

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#93
An alternative approach is to have good shortcuts, Spacemacs being my favourite take on it. The idea is to have shorcuts like ` f e d`. The shortcuts tend to be logically organized in levels (f for files, e for editor, d for dotfile, so this opens your emacs dotfile). No need to remap the keys and no issue with painful key combinations at all.

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#95
I'd feel a bit guilty about remapping somebody's Windows keyboard if I was using their machine for some reason, since even if I had my own user account, the key mapping solutions tend to be global. They'd end up mystified about why the caps lock wasn't working, and it would be basically impossible for them to fix.

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#96
I am surprised there are not more people here that hit the CTRL key with the left part of the palm of their hand rather then twisting the pinky.

I don't think I could even bend my pinky comfortably to do this action.

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#97

I am surprised there are not more people here that hit the CTRL key with the left part of the palm of their hand rather then twisting the pinky. I don't think I could even bend my pinky comfortably to do this action.

I thought the reason why Ctrl was on the bottom left was to use your palm to press it.

All my CS1.6 teammates used this. Learned in compsci classes it wasn't as ubiquitous as is first thought.

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#98
An aside, but I get sad when I see how much tension people have in their hands when they are typing. As a pianist this is the cardinal sin!

Hand size and posture do vary a lot so looking for the right setup is important but learning to be ultra relaxed and effortless in your typing (and chording) is much more portable

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#99

[dead]

Personally found that simply using the other hand for modifiers, moving whole hand laterally without bending the wrist and using thumb to hit the modifier, works much better for me, and afaik that (using the opposite hand) was the original design that impacted Emacs modifiers (with mirrored bucky bits on Knight and Space Cadet keyboards).

A bit of problem due to non-mirrored Alt/Meta (I unfortunately need that AltGr) and problem with laptops that often cut important keys on the right hand side, but reasonably good on full keyboard.

Re: Moving the Ctrl Key

#100

I am surprised there are not more people here that hit the CTRL key with the left part of the palm of their hand rather then twisting the pinky. I don't think I could even bend my pinky comfortably to do this action.

I hit CTRL with my palm too.

I often perform cut/copy/paste with CTRL+Insert,SHIFT+Delete,SHIFT+Insert which is fine on a full sized keyboard. It's why I can't buy so many keyboards that have "optimised" the layout.

Post reply on HN