Live data from Hacker News

Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

usatoday.com

131–140 of 247 posts

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It is effectively legal federally It is not "effectively legal". You cannot do any of these while possessing and/or using marijuana: * Pass federal employment drug tests * ̶F̶l̶y̶ ̶o̶n̶ ̶a̶ ̶p̶l̶a̶n̶e̶ * Buy a gun etc.

Yes, you absolutely can fly with it. TSA has gone on the record, at least in local newspapers, stating that they defer to local police if they find cannabis. If it's for personal use, local PD won't do anything other than suggest you throw it away or else risk punishment if you're flying somewhere legal. I've researched this extensively before flying out of specific airports in legal states up and down the west coast…

Ah, fair enough. I guess that guidance has changed since the last time I looked it up.

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The law outside its application is meaningless. That’s why there’s so many “Did you know it’s illegal to wash your aardvark on Wednesday” laws still on the books. Regarding drugs and guns — how is that enforced? Can’t see how a gun dealer would know. Also, employers can drug test for nicotine, which is legal, and deny employmet.

I picked those examples specifically because they are enforced. > Regarding drugs and guns — how is that enforced? Can’t see how a gun dealer would know. All gun dealers must record form ATF form 4473 for each gun purchase, which specifically asks questions about drug use. If you say yes, you will be denied the gun. If you lie, you may face up to 5 years in prison plus $10K fines. If your state has a medical marijuan…

Circling back to your original point, then: the headline’s framing is misleading because it leaves out potential gun buyers and people applying to federal jobs? Seems like an awfully small minority to be concerned with in… a headline for a national newspaper. How would you write the headline?

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#133

UN has moved to stop resticting it's use for medicinal purposes, but it is still banned for private consumption. As a signatory to the UN drugs convention, US has voted againsy decriminalisation. This is a clumsy summary, ANAL https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/12/1079132

Welp, Canada has ignored that convention and has yet to receive the first or final steps of a UN response: a strongly worded letter. Safe to say we can all ignore that treaty with impunity. edit: Oh and the sky didn’t fall either. If anything, the opposite: marijuana isn’t a cool edgy thing anymore. You just do it if you want to, or don’t if you don’t. The black market still exists, but prices have cratered, so assum…

Canada does a lot of things.

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Welp, Canada has ignored that convention and has yet to receive the first or final steps of a UN response: a strongly worded letter. Safe to say we can all ignore that treaty with impunity. edit: Oh and the sky didn’t fall either. If anything, the opposite: marijuana isn’t a cool edgy thing anymore. You just do it if you want to, or don’t if you don’t. The black market still exists, but prices have cratered, so assum…

Canada does a lot of things.

Mostly resource extraction and real estate financial engineering. Increasingly the latter.

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, the current fillibuster rules require a 60-40 supermajority to get anything done, but the fillubuster rule itself can be changed with a simple majority of 50%+1. But the incentive structure is not there to actually change this rule -- both parties benefit from it.

> both parties benefit from it. Is that really the case? It is a bias towards the status quo. Regardless, IMO the constituents represented by those parties don't benefit from it.

There are “kingmaker” senators in both parties that cross the aisle occasionally, that this rule benefits (and also generally their specific constituents, since their outsize influence gets them more than they might otherwise get in negotiations.)

Given that these kingmakers are what causes things to go over 50-50 they want to preserve their power.

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#136
post #85

Still amazing that the country that started the drugs war is more liberal on this subject than The Netherlands were cannabis is illegal

What’s more amazing is that US states have more autonomy in the matter than EU countries.

Germany’s current legislation attempts are thwarted by EU which prohibits any legal market for the drug.

NL style decriminalization is OK because it’s still illegal, individual users are just not prosecuted and the state turns a blind eye on the shops.

But the shops have to get their supply on the black market - something Germany explicitly does not want.

But EU does not allow a legal market.

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#137

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I picked those examples specifically because they are enforced. > Regarding drugs and guns — how is that enforced? Can’t see how a gun dealer would know. All gun dealers must record form ATF form 4473 for each gun purchase, which specifically asks questions about drug use. If you say yes, you will be denied the gun. If you lie, you may face up to 5 years in prison plus $10K fines. If your state has a medical marijuan…

Circling back to your original point, then: the headline’s framing is misleading because it leaves out potential gun buyers and people applying to federal jobs? Seems like an awfully small minority to be concerned with in… a headline for a national newspaper. How would you write the headline?

Gun owners alone are 1/3 of US adults. The US government is the largest employer in the US (and in the world).

I said how I'd write the headline above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34118464

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The DEA can enforce and arrest people tomorrow if they wanted I’m sure it would go down really really well if the DEA started arresting people for simple possession in states where it’s perfectly legal.

Regardless of your perspective on the morality of it, cannabis is still illegal nationally. Which is the point of this thread To say its legal is simply wrong

Just because there’s a jurisdictional overlap doesn’t make it illegal at state level.

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#139

Prediction: Dems will make a move on federal legalization in the months before the 2024 presidential election, or at least make federal legalization a major election issue. A lot of right wing / libertarian adjacent people were hoping Trump would come out in favor of it as a 2020 election issue, to outflank Biden on at least one issue. It didn't happen, but I bet it would have made the election a bit closer -- it wou…

I used to hold a similar belief but my prediction was that they would do it in two parts: first decriminalize cannabis around the midterms, second, push for legalization around the 2024 election. Decriminalization could have come with talks about performing research, helping minority communities with policing, and allowing banks to work with state producers. Now I just don't think they are as good at political scheming as I thought and potentially that neither party is actually seeking a win so much as seeking drama.

Re: Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks

#140

The headline isn't true. Cannabis is illegal in all of America, since it's still on Schedule I at the federal level. While some states may have removed their own laws against it, that in itself doesn't make it legal there.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B1NggzEkltM

https://www.vice.com/en/article/dp3e4y/the-us-government-has...

There's at least 1 federally legal marijuana patient.

Post reply on HN