Live data from Hacker News

How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

technologyreview.com

41–50 of 148 posts

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#41
post #25

The question I want to ask is: how did Roomba-recorded photos end up in a major publication on the Internet? And the sequence seems to be: 1. iRobot hires people to use special development versions of the Roomba in their homes to collect training data. These are clearly labeled, and the participants are informed that the images are being sent to iRobot for training. This seems fine - if you want to exchange some degr…

No post body was provided.

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#42

Always knew Scale AI was complete BS and overvalued, the lack of controls and oversight is embarrassing, I can't believe they have govt contracts.

Their gov business is questionable for long-term sustainment. Labeling services are akin to transcription services provided by others like Leidos... its not a technology business. Got contracts through political connections...

there's a major turnover in their federal team...

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#43

Yeah, I’m not sure I buy their explanation about special development roombas since they offered zero proof. I have an ancient Roomba that’s still going and dread having to replace it one day.

You don't need to replace it, really.

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#44

Yeah, I’m not sure I buy their explanation about special development roombas since they offered zero proof. I have an ancient Roomba that’s still going and dread having to replace it one day.

Their policy (https://homesupport.irobot.com/s/article/964) seems pretty clear, and from what I've seen of the app it explicitly asks before uploading photos. If you're concerned you can turn the recognition feature off, or block it from the Internet and trigger it manually.

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#45
post #12

Since Scale.ai provides labeling services to the US Department of Defense, how do they address the issues presented in this article? Have their labelers go through government background checks? Provide labeling software but not the labor?

they hire cleared labelers in st louis. The software likely needs to run on-premises or in government networks

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#46

Key paragraph for our friends who don’t RTFA > iRobot … confirmed that these images were captured by its Roombas in 2020. All of them came from “special development robots with hardware and software modifications that are not and never were present on iRobot consumer products for purchase,” the company said in a statement. They were given to “paid collectors and employees” who signed written agreements acknowledging…

Here's a funny bit. Roomba iOS app refuses to go past its welcome screen unless its granted access to the location info. This is unreasonable, they don't need this info for their app to function. However their devices are all but unusable without an app, so they ultimately blackmail people into giving location data to them. Meaning they don't really give a sh#t about users' privacy, so it's not that "they are watchin…

I have a few Roombas and no app. I just hit the button and the robot does its thing.

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#47

Key paragraph for our friends who don’t RTFA > iRobot … confirmed that these images were captured by its Roombas in 2020. All of them came from “special development robots with hardware and software modifications that are not and never were present on iRobot consumer products for purchase,” the company said in a statement. They were given to “paid collectors and employees” who signed written agreements acknowledging…

Here's a funny bit. Roomba iOS app refuses to go past its welcome screen unless its granted access to the location info. This is unreasonable, they don't need this info for their app to function. However their devices are all but unusable without an app, so they ultimately blackmail people into giving location data to them. Meaning they don't really give a sh#t about users' privacy, so it's not that "they are watchin…

Is iOS like Android where Bluetooth permissions are a part of the location info permissions?

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#48
post #30

Clickbait. There is no news here. No privacy was infringed. This was a private dev version.

Pretty sure none of the users consented to photos of them on the toilet being posted on Facebook (and now a news article; wtf was the Tech Review thinking).

Face blurred, no way to see who it is (though I haven't checked for EXIF in the picture, that would be fubar). IMHO and I don't expect anyone else to share it, the picture drives the surveillance aspect home better than word would, though perhaps that makes more of a difference for people who don't ordinarily read Tech Review.

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Here's a funny bit. Roomba iOS app refuses to go past its welcome screen unless its granted access to the location info. This is unreasonable, they don't need this info for their app to function. However their devices are all but unusable without an app, so they ultimately blackmail people into giving location data to them. Meaning they don't really give a sh#t about users' privacy, so it's not that "they are watchin…

Is iOS like Android where Bluetooth permissions are a part of the location info permissions?

No.

Out of spite I took the iPad to a friend's house, enabled location, clicked through the welcome screen and disabled it again. Then came back home and hooked up the device.

So, no, it's not linked to its BT needs at all.

Re: How did Roomba-recorded photos end up on Facebook?

#50

Key paragraph for our friends who don’t RTFA > iRobot … confirmed that these images were captured by its Roombas in 2020. All of them came from “special development robots with hardware and software modifications that are not and never were present on iRobot consumer products for purchase,” the company said in a statement. They were given to “paid collectors and employees” who signed written agreements acknowledging…

Here's a funny bit. Roomba iOS app refuses to go past its welcome screen unless its granted access to the location info. This is unreasonable, they don't need this info for their app to function. However their devices are all but unusable without an app, so they ultimately blackmail people into giving location data to them. Meaning they don't really give a sh#t about users' privacy, so it's not that "they are watchin…

> Roomba iOS app refuses to go past its welcome screen unless its granted access to the location info.

Does anyone know, is this like Android where some bluetooth functionality is behind the location permission?

Post reply on HN