Live data from Hacker News

Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

recurrentauto.com

311–320 of 332 posts

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#311
post #308

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nope. It isn’t that much energy compared to losses in ICE engines/existing inefficiencies. Feel free to do the energy calcs - there is no engineering challenge here for EVs that is currently unsolved.

I prefer practical tests. Right now, however, the authorities here encourage people to avoid using electric pre-heaters in order to save electricity, so I'll take your word for it. :) Ideally, things like this wouldn't be a problem, but where I live EV's is simply not an option during winter. Charging from a regular 240V/16A outlet takes too long, the nearest proper charging station is over 25km away, and the grid ou…

Some specifics -

Assuming Cp = 0.32 kJ/kg•K, which seems about right, you’re talking about 3kwh to heat up a 75kwh sized pack from -25C (-13f) to 25C (77f), or about 4% of the pack capacity. Which about lines up with my experience ‘warming up’ ICE vehicles. It’s not great fuel economy wise to do so.

If you have a block heater, seems like those can be as much as 750-1500 watts. If a diesel, that block needs to get pretty warm, and it’s not like a ton+ of steel/cast iron doesn’t take a lot of energy to heat up either. And that’s ignoring transmission heaters, battery heaters, etc.

Is it 3kwh worth? That would depend on a lot of factors not specified, but it wouldn’t surprise me if it was close.

A 240V/16A outlet (16A is a bit unusual? Usually it’s multiples of 5), is 3.8KW Peak.

That would indeed be limiting, as assuming something like 90% efficiency a full charge is 20+ hours.

It’s an odd number to pick though, as unless someone has a very undersized utility feed, more shouldn’t be a big deal?

I know, some places have only a 50 amp panel and blow fuses anyway, but compared to buying a new car that’s a cheap problem to fix. Even a not shitty welder is going to want 240v/20A, and an old 50 amp panel can barely handle a space heater and other usage.

A typical electric stove is 240v/30A (or more) same with an electric dryer or AC.

If using a typical electric dryer type connection, that’s 7200 watts, and at 90% efficiency could recharge a fully discharged 75kwh pack in 11 hrs, which is ‘overnight’ in most situations.

Most newish residential construction has 150 or 200 amp, 240v split phase service and panels, or 36-48kw, which provides a lot of headroom.

Of course to your point, out in the sticks things are different, and I don’t know your situation or the local counties power infrastructure.

Just supply chain issues would be a show stopper for me in a remote area. Couple in frequent power outages and that it could be life threatening not having a vehicle during one, also an issue.

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#312
post #239
post #179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My gas powered Mercedes heats up just fine without starting the engine. This has been a common feature for like ... idk, 20 years? I think even the 80s W214 had this option, although that used a separate burner system instead of batteries.

You are getting downvoted, while you write the truth. High end cars had that feature for years. Lower end ones used various block heaters / car heater boxes / webastos.

[deleted]

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#313
post #301

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> "Surely pretty much any equivalent gas car remote cabin heating too, it's a very common feature." Remote cabin heating in a gas car requires a "remote start" feature, which is illegal in many European countries - particularly Germany. This is not a common feature in Europe, except in EVs.

No it doesn't. It just requires an auxiliary heater, which has been a common feature in cars sold in Europe for at least 20 years. It's a feature you can find in cars sold during the 80s, like the W214. > This is not a common feature in Europe, except in EVs. It's a common feature in fancy cars and has been so for ages. Most EVs definitely fall into the fancy car category.

Fair point, but what, maybe 5% or so of gas cars are fancy enough to have a fuel-burning auxiliary heater in Europe? (not just Scandinavia)

Where as most EVs have a "remote HVAC control" feature - even the pretty basic ones. And EVs, of course, will cool the cabin in summer time as well, something that an auxiliary heater can't do.

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#314

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plenty of people drive EVs in the arctic far north of Norway (Troms & Finnmark). Not quite as cold as Canada, maybe, but close. Of course EVs will have less range in cold conditions, but they also have some advantages in the cold: pre-heating from an app so the car is warm when you set out, for example. They may be more reliable than petrol and diesel vehicles in extreme cold conditions, and no need for engine block…

> far north of Norway (Troms & Finnmark). Not quite as cold as Canada, maybe, but close. Not even close! The Gulf Stream keeps them nice and toasty. Tromsø or Hammerfest, for example, sees wintertime overnight lows similar to e.g. Worcester, Massachusetts (28 degrees of latitude further south). A far cry from places like North Dakota where the daytime highs in December and January are colder than the overnight lows i…

The interior of Finnmark in northern Norway can get very cold indeed. Temperatures approaching -40 degrees are not unheard of there. The coast is much warmer most of the time as you say.

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#315
post #181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nearly every modern gas vehicle has remote start, and has for years. This isn't an EV feature.

Wow. That would be "nearly every modern gas vehicle in north America". Seriously. Running a cold petrol engine under low load in freezing conditions only for heating i just simply a bad idea. Never understood how this is even remotely OK in the US. This is illegal in most of Europe. And for good reason. If it is around Celcius -40 then you would never turn off the vehicle. And a bit over that - there is always the Ru…

For $30-40 you can buy a block heater. They are a very nice to have in cold weather.

https://www.amazon.com/KENUOS-Thermostat-Self-Adhesive-Dipst...

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#316

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought electric block heaters were common in cold climates. Is the blow torch a last resort if you cannot park your car in range of an outlet?

Maybe in Norway or Canada or other 'rich' countries. Most people have no place to park their cars, they just leave them wherever in the open (since most live in apartments and there are few garages available). Those who have enough money to afford an alarm system and pay the increased gasoline bill (because it adds about an hour of idling your engine each day) rarely revert to such measures, but many do. I see them e…

That makes EVs look even worse.

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#317

My fuel economy drops about 20% on my petrol car in cold weather city driving. I don't know what causes the difference, perhaps waiting for the car to warm up and windows to defrost.

Cold air is denser and takes more work to push through.

This. At highway speeds, air resistance dominates the energy consumption. It is roughly proportional to air density, which in turn is inversely proportional to temperature. Compare a nice summer day at 300 K, say, to a really cold day at 240 K. That’s a ratio of 5:4, pretty close to the 20% figure mentioned.

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#318
post #311

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I prefer practical tests. Right now, however, the authorities here encourage people to avoid using electric pre-heaters in order to save electricity, so I'll take your word for it. :) Ideally, things like this wouldn't be a problem, but where I live EV's is simply not an option during winter. Charging from a regular 240V/16A outlet takes too long, the nearest proper charging station is over 25km away, and the grid ou…

Some specifics - Assuming Cp = 0.32 kJ/kg•K, which seems about right, you’re talking about 3kwh to heat up a 75kwh sized pack from -25C (-13f) to 25C (77f), or about 4% of the pack capacity. Which about lines up with my experience ‘warming up’ ICE vehicles. It’s not great fuel economy wise to do so. If you have a block heater, seems like those can be as much as 750-1500 watts. If a diesel, that block needs to get pre…

Most of the grid here was built with Marshall plan money after the war and has barely been touched since. Renovations are under way but will take another decade or so. And yes, outages are frequent.

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#319

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What percentage of cars on the road are EV in Norway?

> according to Statistics Norway, in 2021 almost 6,000 million kilometres driven by passenger cars were powered by electricity. The total number of kilometres driven by passenger cars was 35,000 million, so EVs still account for less than 20%. (I just stuck your comment into Google.)

This is a case of the government picking winners with tax incentives for adoption, and distorting the market. Tax credits don't change physics.

Re: Winter & Cold Weather EV Range Loss in 7,000 Cars

#320
post #301

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No it doesn't. It just requires an auxiliary heater, which has been a common feature in cars sold in Europe for at least 20 years. It's a feature you can find in cars sold during the 80s, like the W214. > This is not a common feature in Europe, except in EVs. It's a common feature in fancy cars and has been so for ages. Most EVs definitely fall into the fancy car category.

Fair point, but what, maybe 5% or so of gas cars are fancy enough to have a fuel-burning auxiliary heater in Europe? (not just Scandinavia) Where as most EVs have a "remote HVAC control" feature - even the pretty basic ones. And EVs, of course, will cool the cabin in summer time as well, something that an auxiliary heater can't do.

It's definitely much more than 5% of new ICE cars.
Post reply on HN