Live data from Hacker News

Forgejo

forgejo.org

11–20 of 44 posts

Re: Forgejo

#11
post #10

Does any commit to forgejo benefit gitea ltd also? What about other way around (while gitea is still opensource - is it, btw?) Or how does a soft fork work?

A soft fork means Forgejo will be periodically pulling from Gitea.

As far as I know they intend to upstream patches they make as well.

And yes, Gitea is still open source and MIT licensed.

Re: Forgejo

#12

As someone who hasn't been following this: what's the split look like between Forgejo and Gitea for where the contributors are going? Is is mostly going to Forgejo (other than Gitea Inc employees obviously), mostly staying with Gitea, a mix?

As a quick bias note, I am a Gitea maintainer, but a majority of frequent maintainers appear to be staying with Gitea so far. That being said, Forgejo is a soft fork, so they will still benefit from those contributions.

> a majority of frequent maintainers appear to be staying with Gitea

Forgejo was officially launched yesterday...

Also what's a "frequent maintainer"?

Re: Forgejo

#15
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a quick bias note, I am a Gitea maintainer, but a majority of frequent maintainers appear to be staying with Gitea so far. That being said, Forgejo is a soft fork, so they will still benefit from those contributions.

> a majority of frequent maintainers appear to be staying with Gitea Forgejo was officially launched yesterday ... Also what's a "frequent maintainer"?

Yes, but the soft fork discussions began a few days after the first blog post.

I have no real description for a "frequent maintainer", so maybe my wording was incorrect there.

I simply meant someone who contributes to the project often, but I don't have a concrete description for you considering "often" could also be subjective.

Re: Forgejo

#16

As someone who hasn't been following this: what's the split look like between Forgejo and Gitea for where the contributors are going? Is is mostly going to Forgejo (other than Gitea Inc employees obviously), mostly staying with Gitea, a mix?

As a contributor, I will keep watching both and go wherever there seems to be more traction. I don't really care about the ongoing politics.

Re: Forgejo

#17
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a majority of frequent maintainers appear to be staying with Gitea Forgejo was officially launched yesterday ... Also what's a "frequent maintainer"?

Yes, but the soft fork discussions began a few days after the first blog post. I have no real description for a "frequent maintainer", so maybe my wording was incorrect there. I simply meant someone who contributes to the project often, but I don't have a concrete description for you considering "often" could also be subjective.

> someone who contributes to the project often

A frequent contributor then?

"Maintainer" usually implies some sort of admin rights, e.g. the people merging in the contributions.

Re: Forgejo

#19
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, but the soft fork discussions began a few days after the first blog post. I have no real description for a "frequent maintainer", so maybe my wording was incorrect there. I simply meant someone who contributes to the project often, but I don't have a concrete description for you considering "often" could also be subjective.

> someone who contributes to the project often A frequent contributor then? "Maintainer" usually implies some sort of admin rights, e.g. the people merging in the contributions.

We have a list of maintainers, not all of whom can merge, so I apologize for getting this terminology incorrect. I have usually referred to frequent contributors as maintainers interchangeably, but I am glad to have it clarified.

Yes, frequent contributors.

Re: Forgejo

#20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article provides an mp4 that answers this question: https://forgejo.org/static/forgejo.mp4

No way anyone will pronounce it that way.

Now that I know how it's supposed to be pronounced, that's how I'll pronounce it.

So I just invalidated your argument, lol.

Post reply on HN