Live data from Hacker News

Doors of McMurdo

brr.fyi

111–120 of 131 posts

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#111
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The threat is not from strangers, but from fully vetted and trusted community members having some kind of psychological event that leads them to bad actions. The various entities working at McMurdo do pretty thorough pre-deployment psych evals to try to catch the kinds of people who would break vital equipment (think furnaces, or water-treatment equipment or high-cost/one-of-a-kind research equipment) or equipment ne…

They don’t do psych assessments anymore I believe

I've been down with the USAP a couple times, most recently about a decade ago, and in that span the psych eval was required for winterover deployments but not summers. It was very questionable.

I like to think that a spoof "How to Pass the Psych Eval" video we made one winter might've somehow contributed to that particular system being torn down a few years later, though I don't have firsthand experience with the system that replaced it. My understanding is that the new one involves more "team building" type stuff before deployment, which sounds like a step in the right direction.

One issue is that by the time a person has gotten to that late stage in the hiring process, they are often deeply invested in deploying - having packed things in to storage, quit "real world" job, etc. and their nominal manager understands that. Another issue is that people behave differently in different environments, and Antarctica is quite unlike Denver.

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#112

This is not a master-planned community. Rather, it is a series of organic responses to evolving operational needs. over time i have become more and more convinced that this state of affairs is _better_.

I believe all cities people love to visit were built organically by huge numbers if individual actors doing what they thought best with their part of it.

Or are there any preplanned great cities I'm not aware of?

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#113

This is not a master-planned community. Rather, it is a series of organic responses to evolving operational needs. over time i have become more and more convinced that this state of affairs is _better_.

I believe all cities people love to visit were built organically by huge numbers if individual actors doing what they thought best with their part of it. Or are there any preplanned great cities I'm not aware of?

Barcelona gets a lot of love despite most of it being a very regular grid of city blocks.

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#114
Great pictures, but I’ve never seen someone call a doorknob a “rotating handle” before. I guess that is what it is, but there also is a word for it, “doorknob”.

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#115
Looks like they don't really care about heating, as many buildings don't have a vestibule. Where I came from (cold winters) most buildings have a very small room at the entrance, kinda like airlock.

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#116

This is not a master-planned community. Rather, it is a series of organic responses to evolving operational needs. over time i have become more and more convinced that this state of affairs is _better_.

I believe all cities people love to visit were built organically by huge numbers if individual actors doing what they thought best with their part of it. Or are there any preplanned great cities I'm not aware of?

Paris could be considered planned, at least a large part of it: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_...

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#117
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There’s 2/3 bars and a bunch of different parties thrown on different weekends. No wall to wall people though most people need to get up early.

Sadly the bars no longer serve liquor, due to incidents.

mcm has two bars, they both absolutely serve liquor. source: me, a current bartender here in mcmurdo.

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#118
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The threat is not from strangers, but from fully vetted and trusted community members having some kind of psychological event that leads them to bad actions. The various entities working at McMurdo do pretty thorough pre-deployment psych evals to try to catch the kinds of people who would break vital equipment (think furnaces, or water-treatment equipment or high-cost/one-of-a-kind research equipment) or equipment ne…

They don’t do psych assessments anymore I believe

correct, no psych evals for USAP participants.

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#119

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it's better as long as everybody realizes how they got to the current situation, and is willing to continue to make experimental, ad-hoc adjustements to suit the current needs as they change. the problem happens when somebody decides a design that was arrived upon by spontaneous growth is perfect as-is, and when needs change instead of just fixing it, you need a 6-month study and a planning commission to make a chang…

I don't favor arbitrary requirement for studies but I think it's fair to acknowledge that whatever has grown organically over the years does have legitimate reasons why it's the way that it is, even if it wasn't master planned (arguably it probably makes more sense if it evolved) and so you cant really assume that the status quo can be dismissed just because it's not consciously deliberate

It presumably had a good reason for being in each intermediate state before the one you became attached to, and people were presumably attached to those.

Re: Doors of McMurdo

#120

This is not a master-planned community. Rather, it is a series of organic responses to evolving operational needs. over time i have become more and more convinced that this state of affairs is _better_.

They’ve been planning replacing most of the buildings at McMurdo for a new design:

https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/09/the-new-...

Post reply on HN