Live data from Hacker News

Min: A fast, minimal browser that protects your privacy

minbrowser.org

21–30 of 197 posts

Re: Min: A fast, minimal browser that protects your privacy

#21
post #8

Everyone is complaining it is built in electron, and it is a browser running a browser. Brave is also built on electron and is also a browser running a browser.

I’m as anti-Electron as the next person, but my arguments against it are due to the bloat and disrespectful resource usage of using an entire web browser to show local app UI.

But if what you need is an actual, literal web browser, then I’m not sure I see why this is a bad choice.

Re: Min: A fast, minimal browser that protects your privacy

#24
post #3

A browser in electron? At this point just use chromium - makes no difference. Anyway, use firefox or librewolf. Stop enabling the chromium monopoly!

The advantage of Min would be the UI, which I find quite appealing myself.

One might argue this should be a fork of Chromium, not Electron. Chromium comes with native tabs and a bunch of other useful parts, without the security issues that Electron exposes.

Re: Min: A fast, minimal browser that protects your privacy

#25
post #19
post #17

Electron, WebKit, nope. Kudos for experimenting with minimalism! But this is not the alternative to Firefox I've been looking for.

> Electron, WebKit, nope. Electron uses Chromium. Which uses Blink, not WebKit.

Well the worst part of Firefox is arguably Gecko.

If one could make a browser with Firefox's backend and instead render with Blink that would be pretty dope.

Re: Min: A fast, minimal browser that protects your privacy

#26
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Electron, WebKit, nope. Electron uses Chromium. Which uses Blink, not WebKit.

Well the worst part of Firefox is arguably Gecko. If one could make a browser with Firefox's backend and instead render with Blink that would be pretty dope.

> a browser with Firefox's backend and instead render with Blink

Gecko is Firefox's "backend" ...

Re: Min: A fast, minimal browser that protects your privacy

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The advantage of Min would be the UI, which I find quite appealing myself.

One might argue this should be a fork of Chromium, not Electron. Chromium comes with native tabs and a bunch of other useful parts, without the security issues that Electron exposes.

This isn't a fork of Electron. It is an Electron-based app, and as such the Electron project maintains the core functionality of the browser and Min just presents a unified interface and feature set.

Re: Min: A fast, minimal browser that protects your privacy

#30
post #19
post #17

Electron, WebKit, nope. Kudos for experimenting with minimalism! But this is not the alternative to Firefox I've been looking for.

> Electron, WebKit, nope. Electron uses Chromium. Which uses Blink, not WebKit.

Blink is a fork of WebKit.
Post reply on HN