Live data from Hacker News

Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?

slowboring.com

11–20 of 188 posts

Re: Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?

#11
Enrollment is tanking! It did disrupted it, just not in very measurable way! Just the fact people are discussing and questioning value of higher education on social networks, means there is so e disruption!

And YouTube is far better than bored and underpaid postdoc!

Re: Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?

#13
Technology could very well disrupt higher education, but not completely tear it down. Just like Airbnb disrupts hotels but Hotels still exist and are doing better now than ever.

What the future of education looks like is a lot more fractured than we can see in the past. We might think of "higher education" as just a college/university, but in reality there are already alternative forms of higher education and those will continue to be added to.

Sure MooC's seemed like scams, but some MooC's allow a huge scale of knowledge transfer. And some Cohort Based Courses as well, now. I like how Maven talks about courses as "transformational" and not just "knowledge transfer".

I'm looking forward to more and more types of higher education in the near future. Retreats, Online-Only, Hybrid, etc.

Re: Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?

#16
post #12

Credentials

This. More specifically, if a school isn't accredited, you can't get government financial aid to go there

I think that the parent says that while you can learn almost anything from youtube, it is imposible for other people to know that you know something you learned on youtube without a test.

Re: Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?

#18

Enrollment is tanking! It did disrupted it, just not in very measurable way! Just the fact people are discussing and questioning value of higher education on social networks, means there is so e disruption! And YouTube is far better than bored and underpaid postdoc!

Maybe, though I'd guess it has more to do with the realization that the debt isn't worth degree in many cases is starting to sink in.

Re: Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?

#19
Higher education has as much to do with prestige as the education itself. Getting an online education is equivalent to saying you got a diploma through the mail. Maybe it's valid or maybe it's a diploma mill. You can't be sure.

There's nothing equivalent to saying you graduated from an ivy school or such.

Online education is making a dent. Some prestigious universities have an online curriculum and are awarding diplomas that can't be distinguished from a on-campus diplomas but they are the minority by far.

The way I see it. Online education should be a game changer in 3rd world countries. Yet, it doesn't seem to be. It looks like it really does come down to motivation and your ability to push your way through the classes.

Re: Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?

#20
post #14

The article's title is a rhetorical question with answer that ends in: "Motivation and self-discipline are valuable commodities, and an in-person instructor can help provide them."

Among other things. Like being able to clarify things immediately and succinctly instead of having to open yet another tab that turns into a rabbit hole distraction.
Post reply on HN