Live data from Hacker News

Donald Knuth's advice to young people

webofstories.com

1–10 of 17 posts

Re: Donald Knuth's advice to young people

#5
post #3

Is Donald Knuth's approach the complete opposite of the lean startup methodology? Are too many people just trying to follow the latest trends?

His advice was to follow your instinct rather than the herd. I don't see how that's related to learn startup methodology.

Re: Donald Knuth's advice to young people

#6
post #5
post #3

Is Donald Knuth's approach the complete opposite of the lean startup methodology? Are too many people just trying to follow the latest trends?

His advice was to follow your instinct rather than the herd. I don't see how that's related to learn startup methodology.

because the lean startup methodology is currently the herd favorite...

Re: Donald Knuth's advice to young people

#7
post #3

Is Donald Knuth's approach the complete opposite of the lean startup methodology? Are too many people just trying to follow the latest trends?

Too many people are definitely trying to follow the trends, but that is by definition since they wouldn't be be trends otherwise.

But yeah, people need to learn to think independently.

Re: Donald Knuth's advice to young people

#8
post #6
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His advice was to follow your instinct rather than the herd. I don't see how that's related to learn startup methodology.

because the lean startup methodology is currently the herd favorite...

The lean startup methodology is a process for following either the herd (coupons!) or your instinct (something useful).

Re: Donald Knuth's advice to young people

#10
Speaking as a young man, I always found this counter intuitive and here is why (and this is an argument which has been called many things including cute). Wouldn't following the heard be safe? Suppose I don't really want to change the world, rather I want to enjoy myself. Now following the heard is easy, I do whatever everyone else is doing and have the advantage that I can learn from their mistakes. Now I have a large amount of data on what works and what doesn't so I can pick and choose how I wish to follow the heard. On the other hand I have this gut feeling thing which isn't really based on data and more so on... well nothing tangible really. I just feel it may pay out. Their is a high failure rate in such methods and a high frustration attached to it since like minds are rare. So is it that if I want to change the world I should not follow the herd and should follow if I want to just live?
Post reply on HN