Live data from Hacker News

Could The Rebellion Against Traditional Publishing Actually Work?

sebastianmarshall.com

1–10 of 48 posts

Re: Could The Rebellion Against Traditional Publishing Actually Work?

#5

Self publishing maybe the future but it's going to take a while to happen. This article on the other hand is pure marketing.

I read, "All of his cut is directly going to charity". It kinda nulls the argument, even if its marketing.

Re: Could The Rebellion Against Traditional Publishing Actually Work?

#7
Charlie Stross, top SF author and HNer, has a series of articles describing the publishing process: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2010/04/common-m.... He argues that printing and distributing books is only a small part of the process. A polished book still needs literary agents,editors, proof readers, etc. Recommended for the curious.

Re: Could The Rebellion Against Traditional Publishing Actually Work?

#8

Is this guy for real? Or does he transcend our limited notions of "reality"?

Sebastian identifies as bipolar (cyclothymic).

(http://www.mind.org.uk/help/diagnoses_and_conditions/bipolar...)

(http://mentalhealth.gov/health/publications/bipolar-disorder...)

(http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/mentalhealthinfo/problems/bipolardi...)

Re: Could The Rebellion Against Traditional Publishing Actually Work?

#9
post #6

Why does this guy keep getting upvoted on HN?

Because if you don't listen / read too carefully you hear the occasional good thing ("There's a bunch of good people in the chain of making a book; let's treat those people well") and you have it delivered with great enthusiasm and vigour, and some people seem to be able to ignore the copious amounts of ahem additional commentary that is delivered.

Re: Could The Rebellion Against Traditional Publishing Actually Work?

#10

Is this guy for real? Or does he transcend our limited notions of "reality"?

I'm afraid that in its current incarnation, your comment doesn't amount to much more than an insult towards the author. I would elaborate on what makes this crazy in your opinion, and others may discuss your argument.
Post reply on HN