Live data from Hacker News

Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

en.wikipedia.org

11–20 of 49 posts

Re: Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

#11
post #8

Why is domain name supplier a community matter... does the community vet decisions on data-centres or server software?

Neither the Wikimedia Foundation nor the Wikipedia editors participating in the linked discussion seem to think that domain name supplier is a community matter.

As far as I can tell, this was a decision of the Wikimedia Foundation, and the resulting action will be taken by the Wikimedia Foundation.

Re: Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

#12
post #3

It's interesting that they're being criticized. One of the three responses on the page (the other two being positive) is: "This is an overtly political decision. Poor form."

Neutrality is important to their culture, and it could be difficult for some to separate "we don't want to support harmful practices and products" from the politics of those practices and products.

Re: Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

#13
post #3

It's interesting that they're being criticized. One of the three responses on the page (the other two being positive) is: "This is an overtly political decision. Poor form."

I think they are looking at this from the wrong perspective (although it's easy to do). An overly political stance from GoDaddy has forced Wikipedia to make a decision.

It's the same reason why I think Google and other big tech platforms shouldn't use their service to promote anti-SOPA initiatives... once you go down that track, your service is seen as divisive and political.

Re: Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

#16
In a longer run this may not look as good for Wikipedia as it does now. It shows that they are willing to sacrifice their cultural values, particularly neutrality, for other impromptu values that Jimmy sees fit to promote. It also shows that they are willing to turn on their business partners and screw them.

This is the logical next step part of a much longer trend on Wikipedia, that of the solidification of power in the hands of a few, which has been happening with the editing for some time.

Re: Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

#18
post #16

In a longer run this may not look as good for Wikipedia as it does now. It shows that they are willing to sacrifice their cultural values, particularly neutrality, for other impromptu values that Jimmy sees fit to promote. It also shows that they are willing to turn on their business partners and screw them. This is the logical next step part of a much longer trend on Wikipedia, that of the solidification of power in…

Neutrality does not require passivity and inaction. In fact, it requires that you actively distance yourself from politicized parties so that your neutrality is not called into question. GoDaddy has, of their own accord, become a politicized party in the SOPA debate. It is altogether reasonable for Wikipedia to choose not to be involved with them.

Re: Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

#19
post #16

In a longer run this may not look as good for Wikipedia as it does now. It shows that they are willing to sacrifice their cultural values, particularly neutrality, for other impromptu values that Jimmy sees fit to promote. It also shows that they are willing to turn on their business partners and screw them. This is the logical next step part of a much longer trend on Wikipedia, that of the solidification of power in…

  > It shows that they are willing to sacrifice
  > their cultural values, particularly neutrality
Are you sure you did not get it backwards?

Re: Wikipedia will be leaving GoDaddy

#20
post #16

In a longer run this may not look as good for Wikipedia as it does now. It shows that they are willing to sacrifice their cultural values, particularly neutrality, for other impromptu values that Jimmy sees fit to promote. It also shows that they are willing to turn on their business partners and screw them. This is the logical next step part of a much longer trend on Wikipedia, that of the solidification of power in…

OR

It shows that they do care about their users, and they are willing to do whatever it takes to make them comfortable. A few Redditors started a cause to donate money to Wikimedia in return to ask them if they would acknowledge the fact that GoDaddy is/was Pro-SOPA and they should plan on switching their domain over somewhere else.

Jim is also a Anti-SOPA guy, he had the idea to move the domain once the news was out about GoDaddy supporting SOPA. Wikipedia saw an opportunity from their users that were encouraging them to switch.

Along with many others, I also agree with the choice WikiMedia recently made.

Post reply on HN