Live data from Hacker News

Recommendations for Japan Travel

kalzumeus.com

11–20 of 308 posts

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#11
I did notice the change in Japan from 2008 to 2016. Got yelled at by a surly JR ticket person, which I found surprising.

Didn’t like Kyoto as much the second time around but I spent a lot of time outside the big cities and it is such a beautiful country with lovely people.

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#12
post #3

> Note that Japanese reviewers are substantially pickier than you are No kidding, I see lots of reviews like: food is tasty, service was friendly, price reasonable. 3 stars.

When I think about it. I would expect the food I buy to be 1. tasty, 2. reasonably priced, and 3. service should not be rude.

Now up these in anyway and star rating should go to 4 or 5.

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#13
post #3

> Note that Japanese reviewers are substantially pickier than you are No kidding, I see lots of reviews like: food is tasty, service was friendly, price reasonable. 3 stars.

I mean, how else would you distinguish that restaurant from "Food was sublime, service ranged from movie-star charm to invisibly dealing with my every need, payment was waived in favour of a small donation to my favourite cat charity. 5 stars"

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#14

Lovely. Spent 3 months in Kyoto in 2020, at the beginning of the pandemic, and loved Japan, more than my other quick business trips in the past. Some of my notes, specific to Kyoto, but unsure whether they also apply elsewhere: Typical food in KYOTO: - aristocratic kaiseki ryori course dinners - vegetarian shojin ryori of monks - simple obanzai ryori home style cooking - Kyo-wagashi (Kyoto sweets) - Yudofu (tofu cook…

What about Kyoto vs Tokyo? Is there also the "small city" experience (calmer streets, slow people) in those cities, in places away from the center, perhaps?

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#15
I'm not sure when this post was originally written, but at a quick glance I can see some mentioned stores/restaurants that have since unfortunately shut down (like Deus Ex Machina which I used to frequent when it was in Harajuku but has since moved about 45 minutes away to Asakusa). This might not be the most up-to-date resource if you're visiting Japan in the future.

Also, this list specifically recommends the APA hotel chain, whose president leaves copies of his revisionist history book denying the Nanking Massacre in their hotel rooms, often in foreign languages[1]. There are quite a few nationwide hotel chains in Japan like Dormy Inn and JR METS as well as thousands of independents, most of which are listed on price comparison websites and will come in around the same cost as a room at APA. Please consider supporting another hotel, ideally a local one, before APA :)

[1] = many sources, see: https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2017/01/25/national/despit... https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanhatesthis/book-foun...

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#16
post #3

> Note that Japanese reviewers are substantially pickier than you are No kidding, I see lots of reviews like: food is tasty, service was friendly, price reasonable. 3 stars.

Basically, they use the entire dynamic range. 3 stars for "as expected" is eminently sensible, but the west and especially the US suffers so much from review inflation that you could really remove 2 if not 3 stars of a 5-star scale: either a reddit/hn-style up/down, or possibly have a middle-ground "at expectations".

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#17
post #3

> Note that Japanese reviewers are substantially pickier than you are No kidding, I see lots of reviews like: food is tasty, service was friendly, price reasonable. 3 stars.

And American reviewers are pretty much the most generous out there. My rule of thumb is that a 3.5 rating by Japanese equates to a 4.5 rating by Americans. Seriously.

[deleted]

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#18
post #8

"Very few people take me up on this part of the recommendation: get out of the cities if you are here for more than a week in your life." Same situation for visitors to the UK. I've given up trying to tell tourists to get out of London, they never listen.

My new rule of thumb for travel is that if I’ve heard of the city, it probably sucks.

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#19

Going off the beaten path always amuses me a bit as advice (what happens when everyone decides to do that?) but it's also quite true that you can often be literally tens of metres away from the most touristic locations with barely any tourists actually around you in most places (exceptions include cities that have become theme parks like Venice).

Well there are basically 10 places in Tokyo everyone goes to, and maybe they go to Kyoto or Osaka too. That leaves... the entire rest of the country. I've travelled around most of Japan and the majority of time I see zero foreigners.

Seriously just pick a random city from Japan Guide or go to an onsen. Visit Kyushu, it's beautiful and nobody seems to travel there because it's too far away :P

Re: Recommendations for Japan Travel

#20
post #14

Lovely. Spent 3 months in Kyoto in 2020, at the beginning of the pandemic, and loved Japan, more than my other quick business trips in the past. Some of my notes, specific to Kyoto, but unsure whether they also apply elsewhere: Typical food in KYOTO: - aristocratic kaiseki ryori course dinners - vegetarian shojin ryori of monks - simple obanzai ryori home style cooking - Kyo-wagashi (Kyoto sweets) - Yudofu (tofu cook…

What about Kyoto vs Tokyo? Is there also the "small city" experience (calmer streets, slow people) in those cities, in places away from the center, perhaps?

In my xp not for Tokyo. Best you can get is charming alleys but still busy. Kyoto bit better but still a hard sell on that front
Post reply on HN