Live data from Hacker News

GIMP Turns 27

gimp.org

111–120 of 310 posts

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You wouldn't download a car

I would if I could and, now apparently as cars are going to subscriptions for everything, I might eventually need warez for the car.

Cruising down the street with my sweet keygen music, thinking not everything that results because of proprietary software is evil.

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#112
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At this point I don’t think it’s controversial to say that this project existing has harmed creative tools on Linux. If another project had become the de-facto we’d have all those basic features. Instead we’re stuck with something that almost provides the basics ok, because it exists people treat it like a solved problem, and it has such a history no one’s allowed to say it just frankly isn’t usable for it’s one job.

In some ways the de facto standard now is http://www.photopea.com in a browser.

personally I prefer https://pixlr.com/, but then it's mostly because I learned to use it first.

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#113
I use Gimp daily when making screenshots and quickly cropping and resizing afterwards. I've been using it for years!

Huge thank you to Gimp developers that keep it going and congrats on anniversary!

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#114
I was a heavy GIMP user back in the day. Just last week i downloaded again. I didn‘t understand anything. Maybe i just forgot it all, but it felt unusable to me.

The UI seemed so cluttered and unnecessarily complex. Almost like they want to prove how powerful the tool is, by shoving it all in your face. I didn‘t like it.

I think it might be time to reinvent. It would be a shame if GIMP joined the club of 27…

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#115
post #88

For it to have such a bad UX after 27 years is a feat in itself. I can't fathom that to this day people present it as an alternative to Photoshop where it's little more than an unusable Paint. I mean, photopea.com is free, developed by a single guy, and runs in the browser, and it's light years ahead of Gimp.

GIMP is the only software whose UI makes me feel completely stupid. Every 1-2 years, I install it, fire it up to crop an image. I stare at the screen, right click a few times, then I close the app after admitting total defeat. It's been like this for 20 years. A few years ago, I found out that Irfanview runs under Wine. It's a great feeling to understand the UI of a program.

I just categorically disagree that you can conclude anything about GIMP on this basis. I will strongly agree with anyone who says that GIMP is missing features and that it's subpar for graphic designer work. But I've used GIMP for over 15 years now and I have the exact same experience as you when I try to do anything in Photoshop. I simply can't find my way around Photoshop's interface at all. Does that mean that Photoshop's interface is terrible? No. It means I'm not used to it.

The crop tool is literally one click away in the GIMP interface, by the way, and once you activate it, it works like it does in any other program.

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#116

Proves the value of managers breathing down everyone’s necks. It’s a good tool but hasn’t achieved all that much over 27 years.

no - Adobe has GUI and process Software Patents by the boatload for Photoshop.

How is Affinity able to do it?

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#117
post #2

Still no adjustment layers, still no layer styles. It’s so easy to just critique away…but really? Really? Those are just absolutely essential image editing software features. What have they been prioritizing ahead of that?

It's FOSS, so feel free to implement those yourself and send over a PR :)

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#118

I was a heavy GIMP user back in the day. Just last week i downloaded again. I didn‘t understand anything. Maybe i just forgot it all, but it felt unusable to me. The UI seemed so cluttered and unnecessarily complex. Almost like they want to prove how powerful the tool is, by shoving it all in your face. I didn‘t like it. I think it might be time to reinvent. It would be a shame if GIMP joined the club of 27…

Has the UI even changed in 27 years? The fact that the I don't have to relearn it every time I update it has been my favorite feature.

Re: GIMP Turns 27

#120
Why isn't Gimp getting more backing like Blender? Pace of development for it is quite slow which I assume is due to lack of resources?
Post reply on HN