Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Your browser tab count

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 52 posts

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#42

About 4500. Not kidding. Most of it is residue from "I'll read it later" or "I haven't properly understood it" sessions that inevitably crash. I run about ~50-100 (active) tabs at any given time, and the rest are "unloaded". And I don't want to get rid of them because they're a "sequence" of how I came to something (even though I document important stuff). What'll end up happening though, is that one day I'll leave t…

I really like this feature that's in the Vivaldi browser that's called Reading List (Link: https://help.vivaldi.com/desktop/panels/reading-list-panel/) and it solves my bookmark and tab collecting.

My following question is to gain insight and understanding rather than anything malicious and or any sort of judging.

Questions:

- When you've gone back to a tab that has been unloaded, how often has the site been changed when it reloads the data and or just not worked anymore? If you get that a lot, have you considered saving as a single file html or something?

- In your daily life, do you collect and find it difficult to throw away items that you think you'll need at some future point?

- How would you describe your organization style of non-digital items/goods?

- Since you have so many tabs open, how do you search for the things you care about in opened but unloaded tabs?

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#43
6 on desktop and 3 on mobile. I rarely allow my browsers to get above 10 tabs open. Same goes for IDEs and iTerm. If I hit 10 tabs, I generally mass close everything. I don't ever feel productive with that many tabs open. If something is important, I'll bookmark it or throw it in Obsidian.

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#44

About 4500. Not kidding. Most of it is residue from "I'll read it later" or "I haven't properly understood it" sessions that inevitably crash. I run about ~50-100 (active) tabs at any given time, and the rest are "unloaded". And I don't want to get rid of them because they're a "sequence" of how I came to something (even though I document important stuff). What'll end up happening though, is that one day I'll leave t…

I really like this feature that's in the Vivaldi browser that's called Reading List (Link: https://help.vivaldi.com/desktop/panels/reading-list-panel/ ) and it solves my bookmark and tab collecting. My following question is to gain insight and understanding rather than anything malicious and or any sort of judging. Questions: - When you've gone back to a tab that has been unloaded, how often has the site been changed…

>is to gain...

Ah, don't worry about it, his comment put me off a little and I didn't want subsequent comments to snowball.

My browser is messy because it is not my primary organizational structure. It's a dumping ground of sorts that I try to organize by date (tab # in window) and window. The info in most open sequences of tabs is usually saved somewhere, so I don't need to go back to that tab but it's very convenient for quick "reminders" of how I reached a certain position / conclusion / found some info.

> When you've gone back to a tab that has been unloaded, how often has the site been changed when it reloads the data and or just not worked anymore? If you get that a lot, have you considered saving as a single file html or something?

From my OLD tabs (2017 and before) almost everything has changed. I do preserve the cache folders, so occasionally the old version of the website will load (when I enable networking but don't connect to a network). I don't see why it wouldn't work, URL deprecation isn't a very big deal for that time frame. I did use an addon to save some pages as HTML files. I don't remember its name, it was a XUL (pre-webextension) addon.

> In your daily life, do you collect and find it difficult to throw away items that you think you'll need at some future point?

> How would you describe your organization style of non-digital items/goods?

I'm not a hoarder :)

I throw out stuff I don't want / use

As far as information goes, I maintain backups although I usually never go back to them except for very broad file name / tree searches / greps. Storage is cheap and plentiful, what's a few gigs?

> Since you have so many tabs open, how do you search for the things you care about in opened but unloaded tabs?

I use a tabs sidebar extension, and a tab search extension if one isn't natively provided by the sidebar extension. It's also possible to search open tabs from the FF omnibar. Also, the windows / tabs form an ad-hoc organizational structure that's very helpful. Anyway, like I said before, the browser is just my dumping ground. I could lose all but the last 500 tabs and still sleep like a baby.

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really like this feature that's in the Vivaldi browser that's called Reading List (Link: https://help.vivaldi.com/desktop/panels/reading-list-panel/ ) and it solves my bookmark and tab collecting. My following question is to gain insight and understanding rather than anything malicious and or any sort of judging. Questions: - When you've gone back to a tab that has been unloaded, how often has the site been changed…

>is to gain... Ah, don't worry about it, his comment put me off a little and I didn't want subsequent comments to snowball. My browser is messy because it is not my primary organizational structure. It's a dumping ground of sorts that I try to organize by date (tab # in window) and window. The info in most open sequences of tabs is usually saved somewhere, so I don't need to go back to that tab but it's very convenie…

Thank you for your response and insight

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#46
7859.

Firefox seems to have problems around 8000 (or maybe it's just me?), so don't go there :).

If you do, and Firefox crashes at startup, you might need to delete (or better: rename) some files under .mozilla/firefox//:

.mozilla/firefox//sessionstore-backups/recovery.jsonlz4

.mozilla/firefox//sessionstore-backups/recovery.baklz4

.mozilla/firefox//sessionstore.jsonlz4

You'll obviously lose the tabs opened since the last start.

You can have a backup with Tab Session Manager (for Chrome too):

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-session-m...

https://github.com/sienori/Tab-Session-Manager/releases

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#47
20. I use xTab (https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/xtab/amddgdnlkmoha...) which automatically closes the oldest unpinned tab so the count never goes above a user-specified size.

This lets me jump back to recent tabs and I don't miss those that close on their own.

Note: if you use this and use a web-based meeting site like Google Meet, make sure you pin that so you don't get disconnected if you start browsing the web during a meeting.

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#48
I try to keep my tabs to a fairly low count by closing ones I'm not using, though I don't always succeed. At the moment, I've got about 10 tabs open, but that'll likely go down to between 5-8 soon.

Re: Ask HN: Your browser tab count

#49
I'm sort of OCD about open tabs. I close them whenever I'm finished (or think I'm finished). Worst case scenario, I open the browser history and navigate back to what I wanted. This doesn't happen very often. If something needs saving, it goes into my bookmarks.

Slightly unrelated, but I'm the same way on my desktop too. I hate open windows that I'm not actively using. I always force close things on my MacBook.

Edit: To answer the question, 1.

Post reply on HN