Live data from Hacker News

San Francisco considers allowing law enforcement robots to use lethal force

npr.org

1–10 of 74 posts

Re: San Francisco considers allowing law enforcement robots to use lethal force

#4
> The idea of robots being legally allowed to kill has garnered some controversy.

Since these "robots" are not autonomous, you can substitute "guns" for "robots" in the above sentence. The sentence remains true but becomes banal.

The big ethical difference is that the remote trigger puller can no longer justify the act by a threat to their own life, only to other lives.

Re: San Francisco considers allowing law enforcement robots to use lethal force

#5
post #3

Wouldn't it be more helpful to have robots scooping up [stuff] from the sidewalks and sanitizing things?

In Singapore maybe .. this is America! If there's anything we're good at domestically, it's using lethal police force.

Re: San Francisco considers allowing law enforcement robots to use lethal force

#7
post #6

Isn’t the entire point of officers being allowed to use lethal force that their lives are in danger? Killing people remotely when you are completely safe just seems like straight up murder.

Or in the defense of another. It wouldn’t make sense for a robot to take a life to save its own, but it might make sense for it to take a life to save your mother’s.

Re: San Francisco considers allowing law enforcement robots to use lethal force

#8
post #6

Isn’t the entire point of officers being allowed to use lethal force that their lives are in danger? Killing people remotely when you are completely safe just seems like straight up murder.

Or someone else's life is at risk.

Re: San Francisco considers allowing law enforcement robots to use lethal force

#10
San Francisco is weird. My wife and I enjoyed our visit last month where we sat at an outdoor cafe and watched people stealing bikes and furniture (yes, seriously).

I am going to be less entertained by watching murder robots wandering the streets, so perhaps I will eat elsewhere next time.

Post reply on HN