Live data from Hacker News

Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

smithsonianmag.com

11–20 of 493 posts

Re: Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

#11
Going to be great to see people make up reasons not to eat this, when they are fine with all the crap that goes into a cow to keep it healthy and alive long enough to slaughter. Nevermind the crazy chemicals used for milk processing!

You may think, oh - we've been eating that for a while, right? No, not really. It's just about as new as obesity and other modern epidemics we've been dealing with ...

Re: Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

#12

> ...the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) will need to inspect the company’s production facilities and product While I'm not undercutting the work that the USDA places into regulating consumer safety in the food supply chain, isn't it crazy to think that lab-grown meats are probably going to be under higher scrutiny from a food safety perspective than farm grown and butchered meats?

Is it really higher scrutiny, or the same scrutiny USDA applies to farm-grown/butchered meats?

Re: Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

#13
post #8

Yeah I’m going to let other folks experiment with that for 10 or so years and see where it goes. I’m sure the meat is fine, it’s just a matter of not contaminating it during the process that I’m concerned about. The FDA is really poor at enforcing the health and safety aspects of manufacturing and processing. They simply don’t have enough inspectors and the inspectors don’t fine big offenders enough

Or consuming terrifying amounts of energy and resources, when you can put a cow in a field until it's big enough to eat.

Re: Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

#15

> ...the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) will need to inspect the company’s production facilities and product While I'm not undercutting the work that the USDA places into regulating consumer safety in the food supply chain, isn't it crazy to think that lab-grown meats are probably going to be under higher scrutiny from a food safety perspective than farm grown and butchered meats?

I think so, yeah. It isn't crazy b.c that is how lobbying works in the US, but it is crazy b.c you'd expect a lab to be better defacto than a slaughterhouse.

Re: Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

#16

Is there some resource detailing just how thorough the FDA reviews consumption safety? While I doubt this won't pass a long-term test, it'd be interesting to see whether or not food products are tested for long-term effects at different consumption levels, or if they simply test for any immediately concerning issues and constantly watch for illness/health problems that might be attributed to evolving consumption tren…

Here's the company's assessment of why their product is safe: https://www.fda.gov/media/163262/download

And here's the FDA's summary of their findings: https://www.fda.gov/media/163261/download

Re: Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

#17

Going to be great to see people make up reasons not to eat this, when they are fine with all the crap that goes into a cow to keep it healthy and alive long enough to slaughter. Nevermind the crazy chemicals used for milk processing! You may think, oh - we've been eating that for a while, right? No, not really. It's just about as new as obesity and other modern epidemics we've been dealing with ...

> when they are fine with all the crap that goes into a cow to keep it healthy and alive long enough to slaughter

What, like grass and sugar beet pulp?

Re: Lab-Grown Meat Is Safe to Eat, FDA Says

#19
post #8

Yeah I’m going to let other folks experiment with that for 10 or so years and see where it goes. I’m sure the meat is fine, it’s just a matter of not contaminating it during the process that I’m concerned about. The FDA is really poor at enforcing the health and safety aspects of manufacturing and processing. They simply don’t have enough inspectors and the inspectors don’t fine big offenders enough

Or consuming terrifying amounts of energy and resources, when you can put a cow in a field until it's big enough to eat.

One cow is fine, it's when you try to put millions of cows out there and grow them as fast as possible that you get problems.
Post reply on HN