Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Using stylometry to find HN users with alternate accounts

stylometry.net

371–380 of 562 posts

Re: Show HN: Using stylometry to find HN users with alternate accounts

#371

How much should we fear de-anonymisation ? A lot of discussion on the thread are over "how can we prevent this". I would like to know why should we not embrace this and similar technologies? The benefits in my view are large - online behaviour tracks back to real life - and epidemiology speaking the value of millions of test subjects across every question are invaluable - from traditional medicine to "mass psychology…

Fear it happening or fear its consequences? Doxxing already happens all the time, but the main tools are things like account names or image search, this sort of tool could take it to a new level. A simple experiment would be to run this same algorithm against another site (say Twitter or Reddit) and see if it can reliably pick out the same peoples' accounts there. Once anyone on the internet can quickly/easily draw that sort of connection it would require incredible diligence to avoid de-anonimyzation while still maintaining any sort of "real self" presence on the internet. How much we should fear the consequences probably depends a lot on how marginalized you are within your society, but since just revealing your gender is enough to invite harassment in many forums I'm not optimistic.

Re: Show HN: Using stylometry to find HN users with alternate accounts

#372
post #208

How about this for countermeasure: As you're typing out a comment the software gives you a list of accounts you're becoming similar to. That way you can adjust your writing as you type.

Sounds great, except there are many different similarity measures. Which one does the algorithm use?

Why not all of them? Which metrics are closer would tell you which aspects of your writing you need to focus on.

Re: Show HN: Using stylometry to find HN users with alternate accounts

#374
post #336

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good point - I've been running john on that md5 for a couple minutes :)

Why use John? Just run down the list of Hacker News usernames; it'll take less time. (Or, better still, don't; just because the privacy's theoretically compromised doesn't mean we have to exploit that.)

I don't think there's a public list of all HN usernames is there?

Found this, it includes 250k usernames, but it's not there. https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/hacker-news/hacker-news-corp...

Re: Show HN: Using stylometry to find HN users with alternate accounts

#375
post #105

After a few tries on boring accounts, I thought to try the account of somebody who was notorious for an incident outside of HN, and had a (deservedly) bad time at HN for a couple of years before the account went dark. And yeah, there's a bunch of high confidence (.6-.8) hits for that account, and from a quick browse of the comments of the recently active ones, they look really likely to be alts. Like, all three that…

MD5 of the username is 9abc27e93b7e3c04b7c599017c1cfe5f ? The top one seems an odd one out in that case?

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Using stylometry to find HN users with alternate accounts

#376
post #374

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why use John? Just run down the list of Hacker News usernames; it'll take less time. (Or, better still, don't; just because the privacy's theoretically compromised doesn't mean we have to exploit that.)

I don't think there's a public list of all HN usernames is there? Found this, it includes 250k usernames, but it's not there. https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/hacker-news/hacker-news-corp...

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Using stylometry to find HN users with alternate accounts

#380
post #231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There're 19 other accounts this tool finds similar to me. Those are not my accounts. 0.46 - 0.56 are numbers.

I think people are sort of confused at what this tool is supposed to be which I will concede is partially my fault. The results of this tool are by themselves not indicative of having an alternative account. It generates the 20 most similar users for every single user on the site, regardless of whether they have an alt or not (there's obviously no way for me to know that for every single user). In your case further i…

It is a fun tool, I can assure you. It is just people have found use case you haven't foreseen yourself.

I think your tool should have internal embeddings for each of the user. Also, most probably your tool uses cosine similarity for a search.

Thus, I would like to suggest a feature: recognize simple arithmetic operations over user's embeddings, such as "thesz - 2 * patio11". It will make things even more fun, this way we can find users who are like me and much not like patio11. Even simple additions and subtractions would suffice.

(an idea is taken from properties of word2vec embeddings)

Your tool is thought provoking. What I discovered with it made me think about my use of language and what other languages (body, imagery, etc) I use differently because of who I am. Which made me think about my favorite underrated superhero Cypher [1] - would his innate ability to understand languages make him best detective ever?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cypher_(Marvel_Comics)

Thank you!

Post reply on HN