Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 99 posts

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#11

HN is a respite from those awful cookie banners, that's something.

Dark pattern banners I call them. One day I clicked the 'more options' button on a foreign website and it was a list of over 1000 different third parties listed each with their own toggle.

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#13
post #6

I can’t wait for the day the EU actually tries to enforce their laws on individuals and companies with no presence there. Will be a fun extradition battle to watch

It's such an absurd thing to even try and attempt. I have no doubt they will.

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#14
I’ve always found it funny people think GDPR matters outside of the EU.

You cannot regulate a steel manufacturer in China from the EU. Similarly, you cannot regulate how a company and server is setup in another country. It’s where the company is operating.

In the case of hacker news the CCPA probably does have an impact. So i suspect they follow the appropriate law there. That’s because that’s where they are operating out of.

That said, HN is moderated pretty well. I suspect if you ask them they’ll tell you and / or delete what ever you ask.

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#15

Maybe the lack of any kind of business relationship matters? I.e. HN isn't making money from the people posting here.

Eh, ycombinator definitely benefits from HN as an advertising method and has information on people that use HN, so there's only no sort of business relationship if you also believe that other major advertisers (such as Google) have no business relationship that applies.

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#16
post #12

HN is a respite from those awful cookie banners, that's something.

And those banners aren't even mandatory. Someone did it without learning the actual law and almost everybody does that.

They are mandatory if by browsing a website your data ends up in a 3rd party, which means almost all websites.

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#17

There seems to be a legal theory that public discourse is not to be removed under the GDPR. Discord, for example, will also not delete your messages. Part of the problem is also that the government agencies tasked with regulating these things are hopelessly slow in pursing matters, especially when non-EU companies are concerned.

Because, as has been pointed out ad nauseam THEY HAVE NO JURISDICTION to tell US companies what to do.

Of course, every time I point this out, people get mad at me because they happen to like the law (ie, they like the idea of privacy, and privacy theatre is comforting to them).

I'm personally of the opinion that one government telling me what to do is quite enough, thank you very much.

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#18

There seems to be a legal theory that public discourse is not to be removed under the GDPR. Discord, for example, will also not delete your messages. Part of the problem is also that the government agencies tasked with regulating these things are hopelessly slow in pursing matters, especially when non-EU companies are concerned.

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?

#20
CCPA states: The right to know the personal information that businesses have collected from an individual The right to opt-out of the sale of consumer data collection The right to delete personal information collected from them

HackerNews doesn't collect personal data.

Deleting anything someone wants deleted isn't covered

Post reply on HN