Live data from Hacker News

Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

frontiersin.org

241–250 of 354 posts

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#242

What do others here think about casual use of the word "crazy" in a work setting. For instance, "that's a crazy idea" or "they're crazy to think ...."

It's the same as with other words, including the some of the "x-words" (the n-word, c-word, f-word, p-word, and whatever else Americans came up with). They should all be possible to write and utter as long as they are not written and uttered as a slur.

Saying that "something is crazy" doesn't really victimize anybody. Intention should matter much more than it currently does. I really hope we are at the point where the pendulum swings back to the place where people understand that again.

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#243

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see anything wrong with the term "dopamine hit". It's the main neurotransmitter involved in the brain's reward system. Rewarding stimulus is exactly what is meant by popular use of the term. I really don't understand attempts to problematize the use of this term. Sure, there are other neurotransmitters involved and dopamine is also present in other systems and even in the rest of the body. Nobody denies that.

The problem is the dumbing down of complex mechanisms into sound bites. Both dopamine and rewards systems are a lot more complicated than they're presented and not very well understood. But you can buy self-help/popsci books that give you very incorrect simplistic pictures of how these things work. Maybe the term "dopamine hit" is fine when it's just that, but people base their whole understanding of their brain base…

Yes, I agree that it's dumbed down but not everything has to be a scientifically accurate discussion. I think it's a useful term to easily communicate complex concepts. Dopamine hit for any pleasurable addicting stimulus. Dopamine dripfeed for social media's endless stream of tailored content. The word dopamine is in there to associate the idea with addictive drugs and the way they take over the brain's reward center.

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#244
post #185

I am surprised there is no mention of the word "histrionic" which is completely out-of-date and insulting to women.

How so? "Histrionic" has no relation to "hysterical."

If two words aren't related it can still be a problem if people think they are, and language evolution will start treating them as if they are (backformation).

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#245
It's strange that they don't offer "recommendations for preferable terms" for every term. Or, at least example sentences with the terms to avoid removed and replaced with more appropriate language. Clearly these terms are being used because authors find them useful. Without guidance on how to replace them, authors will probably keep using them.

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#246
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think there's a difference between police-ing speech, and clarifying it. Language is hard, and misunderstandings are surprisingly common, and many world's evils comes from pure misunderstanding. Most misunderstandings arise from people having different understanding of same words - so approaching agreement on the meaning of words is important to reduce misunderstandings. The problem is the language is self-manifest…

Quoted post unavailable.

Virtue signalling is a good thing and an essential part of leadership.

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#247

It's strange that they don't offer "recommendations for preferable terms" for every term. Or, at least example sentences with the terms to avoid removed and replaced with more appropriate language. Clearly these terms are being used because authors find them useful. Without guidance on how to replace them, authors will probably keep using them.

A lot of the terms on this list describe things that simply don’t exist, so the implicit suggestion is to not make shit up. To, y’know, research what you’re writing about rather than just repeat mistruths.

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#248
post #221
post #218

The "steep learning curve" entry is bizarre. Is it so difficult to envision that it's a straightforward analogue to real life? Climbing a steep mountain (that is, a steep slope or curve), if you manage (since a difficult traverse is going to turn away a lot of people, just like a steep learning curve), you are going to end up with a good view (or understanding of the field). It was never about a X=time, Y=distance ma…

Your disagreement with their assessment is exactly why they say it should not be used. There are two equally plausible interpretations, and as a technical term, theirs is correct, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learning_curve

IMO, since they're not suggesting anything better they are not helping. It's like telling people "just don't do that if it's causing problems". Well, what's the alternative? We still have this concept we need to communicate effectively, of something that's hard but possible to learn if you spend a lot of energy on it, analogous to how you spend a lot of energy climbing a steep hill.

Also, have you ever met anyone who thought "steep learning curve" was ambiguous? This seems like a controversy invented by some really literal-minded people who are not representative of the general population.

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#249

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I sure hope social psychologists don't use torture. Read up on psychologist’s participation in the Guantanamo prison camp torture program. Indeed many psychologists did use torture, and it is something of a really dark spot in the history of the American Psychology Association.

The broader history of psychiatry has so many dark spots one might confuse it for a dalmatian.

The broader history of almost any profession/industry is similarly checkered. Engineering, farming, medicine, charity/aid… humans will do bad things whatever field they’re in.

Re: Psychological and psychiatric terms to avoid

#250
Not on the list: "Oh, it's just my OCD" -- Either you have been diagnosed (and consequently suffer from OCD) or you have an obsessive personality (sometimes a quality).

But OCD is a diagnosis, abusing it do describe a personality trait doesn't serve the many many people impacted by the disorder.

-- From someone with an affected loved one.

Post reply on HN