Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 515 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click?

#71
Engineering:

Third year math phys and its accompanying book (McQuarrie). It blew my mind when I learned McQuarrie is a chemist.

Engineering's role in society:

Schumacher's "Small is beautiful" and "Guide for the perplexed" was the straw finally broke me free of the technocrat worldview. (Although Illich's argument that a car's average speed is 3mph made me question my love for cars)

Re: Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click?

#72
post #52

I had a very poor model of what people meant when they spoke of divinity, god, and religion until reading the Tao Te Ching. Whenever I heard god, I just thought of sky daddy. The key is to understand that religion is a map, not the territory. All religions are essentially different paths to the same destination, mixed with varying levels of human interpretation.

What is it about that book that made it click? There's an awful lot of people who believe in sky daddy. What did they miss?

Not GP, but I have a similar experience. The Tao Te Ching presents a kind of supreme entity which is the unity underpinning all things. It questions dichotomy and difference and scarcity and control, as these things are only possible in a world of differentiated objects. We can’t always be present to this Unity because sometimes we need to eat a sandwich. But the book is a nice reminder—“hey, we all come from the same place and we’re all going to the same place.”

If you Are extremely analytical, maybe when someone says “God”, do a text replace with “the laws of physics and the initial conditions of the universe”. If what the other person is saying still makes sense, then they aren’t a sky daddy believer.

The universe doesn’t want or command, but it certainly does require and allow.

You share an incredibly tight light cone with all things on earth, living and non-living, so you can assume that your causal relationships with everything and everyone around you are highly intertwined.

Re: Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click?

#73
"The Way of Zen" by Alan Watts.

In its first chapter there's the best and only compelling argument I've ever read in favour of spirituality and why people believe in God. Even an ultra-atheist like me finally got why people have faith. There are obvious blind spots in science and logic that can't be explained away with more theorems.

If logic is pointed thought, it's good to recognize there's some things that can only be seen by unfocusing your mind. Some shadows only appear in your peripheral vision.

Re: Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click?

#75
There are many different books and courses on thermodynamics, but as far as fundamental worldview, that's the most significant 'before and after' viewpoint shift, 'oh that's how everything works' experience. Everything is system and surroundings, and it's basically arbitrary how you divide up the universe into system and surroundings, although there are obvious natural divisions (sun and planets as a relatively isolated system, biosphere of a planet, physical boundary of a living organism, etc.). Peter Atkins does a good job with his books and lectures on the topic, for example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSuXS_zqRec

However, what generally happens is something 'clicks' and you get it for a while, then you realize you only had a low-level understanding, so then you get into higher-level abstractions, and it 'clicks' again, and so on.

Re: Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click?

#76
As someone who was preparing for International physics Olympiad in heydays in senior year of high school, reading Feynman Lectures of Physics (especially part-2 on Electrodynamics), made the real difference. I was reasonably prepared competing at regional level, but Feynman's way of prodding the deep questions made me realize how many cracks I had missed. It also helped me build the skill of stopping at a reasonable point - its incredibly easy to keep grappling at really hard problems which may never lead to solution with existing skillsets. Judging what you don't know & incapable to solve is very important and perhaps applicable to all disciplines.

Re: Ask HN: Do you recall any book or course that made a topic finally click?

#80
post #8

Brent Yorgey's Introduction to Haskell: https://www.cis.upenn.edu/~cis1940/spring13/ Rudin's "Principles of Mathematical Analysis" is a brilliantly lucid introduction to the topic that takes a completely unconventional approach.

Baby Rudin greatly deserves it's hallowed place. In many ways it was the book that got me into mathematics
Post reply on HN