Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 34 posts

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#11

Would love to see a HN for aviation startups. Unfortunately most every time I see an aviation startup, it’s the same silly hot garbage. If I see one more multicopter based autonomous air taxi service, or magical supersonic transport for savage good boys pitched, I’m gonna scream. (Context - 20+ years experience in product development engineering and new/derivative product launch at a large airframe manufacturer.)

Be the change you want. People are very receptive in that space. In a past life my team and I were starting to bring together a lot of connections. We started by asking our NX rep. for reference accounts. Those were people doing what we were, using the tools we were, and who had agreed to let Siemens give out their contact info. We were really surprised at the list we got and the people we were then able to connect with, and how open they were to just communicating on stuff.

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#12

Not related to mechanical engineering, but I always wonder why there is such less discussion of real world product design. It's almost like we take stuff for granted. What type of degree would one need to develop a career designing stuff like lunch tiffin boxes or shoes or the other hundreds of myriad things we use in daily life? So many people seem obsessed with CSS and JS here.

I've made a career of doing this. I got in through the Medical Device door but have since designed all kinds of stuff from small implanted medical devices to giant projector enclosures and outdoor video walls for those giant mouse themed parks in California and Florida. Happy to answer any questions, I have a website with more info and contact details.

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#13
post #10

There are always newspaper titles saying "we need more engineers", "where are all the engineers" or something similar. To answer that. It's simple. The pay is bad. We study for 4-5 years to get an Mech engineering degree and are promised 80K AUD+ starting salary (by many Australian universities). The truth is you end up in debt whilst being removed from the work force for 4-5 years while studying. And you end up earn…

the prompt wasn’t questioning why there aren’t more - it was asking where they hang out online.

The question is in the title. I addressed the title, but what I said still applies. There are less Mech engineers to hang out online because they swap to other fields.

I understand what you are saying but this is also a comment. No one is obliged to answer someones prompt when commenting.

Also my comment was based on my own experiences and the experiences of my peers. Out of a cohort of 300 engineers by the end of the course 80 to 90% dropped. Now when ever I meet someone who wants to go into engineering I tell them to step back do your own research, consider the ROI and determine if you want to do it because you love engineering or if you just want to make money.

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#14
post #10

There are always newspaper titles saying "we need more engineers", "where are all the engineers" or something similar. To answer that. It's simple. The pay is bad. We study for 4-5 years to get an Mech engineering degree and are promised 80K AUD+ starting salary (by many Australian universities). The truth is you end up in debt whilst being removed from the work force for 4-5 years while studying. And you end up earn…

the prompt wasn’t questioning why there aren’t more - it was asking where they hang out online.

If they end up doing software they probably hang out here ;) The other ones, I have no idea.

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#15
post #10

There are always newspaper titles saying "we need more engineers", "where are all the engineers" or something similar. To answer that. It's simple. The pay is bad. We study for 4-5 years to get an Mech engineering degree and are promised 80K AUD+ starting salary (by many Australian universities). The truth is you end up in debt whilst being removed from the work force for 4-5 years while studying. And you end up earn…

the prompt wasn’t questioning why there aren’t more - it was asking where they hang out online.

Maybe Hackaday and its forums

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#16

There are always newspaper titles saying "we need more engineers", "where are all the engineers" or something similar. To answer that. It's simple. The pay is bad. We study for 4-5 years to get an Mech engineering degree and are promised 80K AUD+ starting salary (by many Australian universities). The truth is you end up in debt whilst being removed from the work force for 4-5 years while studying. And you end up earn…

I've made a career as a mechanical engineer. My experience has been the opposite of yours, actually, it's been similar.

I've worked at companies that had positions and work cultures like you describe. I've also worked at amazing positions with extraordinary cultures and compensation.

I've been told multiple times, by multiple people that "your smart, you should go into finance". Each time it was right before a big crash, where finance bros were looking for work.

Over the years I've focused on keeping myself busy working on new things, learning new skillsets, and bettering myself. It doesn't really matter that specific discipline you practice, if you are the kind of person that continuously adds to and refines their skills and track record of delivering, that person is then able to charge a premium for that skillset. It doesn't matter if your a jeweler, writer, chef, mechanical engineer.

All this to say, I'm a mechanical engineer, I've designed a ton of cool things, I do it every day. I deeply love it, and get better at it every day because I want to.

I have been fortunate to also have risen above the negatives the commenter above mentioned (low pay, lack of upward mobility, working on not fun stuff like file transitions or whatever). I started in a lower opportunity area, worked my way up through those types of jobs, was able to move myself and my family to a higher opportunity area (SF bay area in my case) and now I lead the design and company building efforts l, do thebfun stuff and contract out the boring stuff like file transitions and sheet metal manufacturing to companies in lower cost of living, lower cost to do business, lower opportunity areas.

All this to say I think that each technical discipline you can choose outside of academia focused things, has pretty equal opportunity, it's far less of a factor than the other factors in your career like location and the types of companies you are working at.

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#17
post #10

There are always newspaper titles saying "we need more engineers", "where are all the engineers" or something similar. To answer that. It's simple. The pay is bad. We study for 4-5 years to get an Mech engineering degree and are promised 80K AUD+ starting salary (by many Australian universities). The truth is you end up in debt whilst being removed from the work force for 4-5 years while studying. And you end up earn…

the prompt wasn’t questioning why there aren’t more - it was asking where they hang out online.

I am one, I hang out here, Hackaday, the sparkfun and adafruit blogs, there is a solid design focused blog thing called "solidsmack". There is a cool podcast "being an engineer" (I'm one of the guests!).

Re: Ask HN: Where are all the mechanical engineers?

#20

Not related to mechanical engineering, but I always wonder why there is such less discussion of real world product design. It's almost like we take stuff for granted. What type of degree would one need to develop a career designing stuff like lunch tiffin boxes or shoes or the other hundreds of myriad things we use in daily life? So many people seem obsessed with CSS and JS here.

The technical university where I live has “Industrial design engineering” which sounds a bit like designing various “things”.
Post reply on HN