Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 239 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#32
To me, regardless of what you call it, it comes down to two things: 1. finding something you enjoy/willingly put great effort into, 2. looking back on your life at the end and not regretting the time spent.

I can't say I know I've found mine but I have from a young age enjoyed understanding and making machinery, now extended to software. I try to improve and apply my ability at a company that doesn't suck and share anything useful I've learned. I still greatly enjoy learning and applying new knowledge in this area.

Conversely every now and then, I wonder if I wouldn't have more appreciated following an artistic path, say off the top of my head like Aphex Twin (without the fame & success). Probably some of both makes sense. The most important thing is probably not to get caught up not doing anything. You rarely know it's "the thing" while you're doing it, only in retrospect might you realize it was.

Caveat: enjoying (1) is optional if (2) is significant enough and you can endure. :-)

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#33
post #4

> I think this is the kind of thing a fair amount of people here in HN have thought about, so I thought of asking. It would truly surprise me if many people _actively_ find their purpose, and it would surprise me almost as much if most people find theirs at all. Mine, i discovered rather by accident while not thinking about it at all. Instead, it simply occurred to me one day that i had found, and been living, my pur…

Good to hear that. How did it happen? Any suggestions to move towards that direction? If you feel comfortable, you can share your purpose finding journey. And what happened next?

> How did it happen?

i was walking down the road doing something completely unrelated, not thinking about anything in particular, and it hit me.

> Any suggestions to move towards that direction?

If it doesn't happen on its own, it seems unlikely to me to ever happen. It's like falling in love: if you look for it, if you try to force it, it's not going to work.

> If you feel comfortable, you can share your purpose finding journey.

My purpose is not to change the world, but to support those who do. i've spent approximately a quarter of my life supporting/contributing to Richard Hipp's projects (mainly the Fossil SCM and, more recently, sqlite), and have found that niche to fit my purpose perfectly. It was, however, only about a year ago that i realized that that was my purpose.

> And what happened next?

Same thing as the day before: keep contributing.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#35
I spent a lot time on this topic and in the end, I settled with "reproduction of genes". Maybe I am not exactly going to pursue my purpose, but it feels good to know once I pass on my genes, I have accomplished my purpose. Then I just enjoy my life without worrying about my purpose.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#36
post #17

One notable person's answers to your question: https://sive.rs/faq I found them useful, myself. Derek's "Don't Be A Donkey" post is also applicable here: https://sive.rs/donkey Have you considered that the question may be a trap and/or pointless to begin with?

I have considered it, and that may be the answer. However, studies do show that "have a purpose" is correlated with happiness.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#37
Finding the thing that drives you is probably not something you can study for. Try meditating. You might come to the conclusion that you just want to be a parent, or you maybe come to the conclusion that you want to make humans an interplanetary species.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#38
I don't think you should buy it; you've been programmed to believe it so that it becomes self-fulfilling prophecy. I think people are more satisfied with life when they have a purpose because they think they need a purpose, but that seems to me like a symptom of a prevalent mode of thought--Heidegger described the modern myth that we work with is that everything kind of represents a flat plane of potential to exploit and turn into utility or usefulness, and searching for some kind of overriding purpose seems like a consequence of that.

I think you should just explore religion (esp. Zen, Dzogchen, Mahamudra, Advaita), philosophy, literature, and yourself through first person experience until you intuitively feel the error of this entire mode of thought. It won't do to tell yourself that, although reaching the conclusion analytically makes for a first step. You have "meaning" and "purpose" sapping assumptions built into you, like modern materialist reductionism. Reductionism says that a thing amounts to the sum of its parts, but it's obviously fallacious. Try cutting a cat in half and putting the two parts back together and seeing if you have what you started with. Reductionism is a powerful mode of thought in certain circumstances, but it's not absolutely true.

I think we need to acknowledge what there is outside of ourselves, and recognize that the universal is always and only found in the the particular. Every blade of grass is alive with meaning, but it doesn't speak it in terms of utility and materialist reductionism.

Re: Ask HN: How do I find my “purpose”?

#40
Well, I think a change in perspective might help. Namely, you do not find your purpose because it's not lost. You create or choose your purpose. A purpose is not necessarily inherent, or given to you by the Universe. On a related note, work hard to understand that point enough to stop feeling bad about not having one. We evolved to want a purpose or goals for fitness purposes, but there's no rule coming from the Universe that says you're supposed to have one. That can be liberating to realize. On the other hand, you do have built in constraints as a human. So, when creating a purpose, I think it's useful to start with Maslow's hierarchy. Do you have the base levels covered. What about the one's above that? Etc. If not, then I think you should mainly make your purpose getting those needs filled before expanding. If you're lucky enough to live in the USA, or another such country, and you get a reasonably good education, then you probably already have basic needs taken care of. Part of your purpose, then, is to maintain your basic needs. Once you're good there, I would focus on researching well being and happiness. Make your main purpose exploring which of those things works for you. Purpose itself is one of those things, so this is self-referential, but there are many other things. Pay attention to your unique combination of traits and strengths. Which of those will give you the best chance of making an impact in your own life and in the world. Can you make any of those your purpose? Keep exploring. Importantly, I think mindfulness training will help give you a way to enjoy or be at peace moment to moment, so explore that too.
Post reply on HN