Live data from Hacker News

Signal Introduces Stories

signal.org

411–420 of 480 posts

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#411
post #226

Please bring back SMS support. It's hard enough to convince people to use Signal in the first place. Nobody is going to juggle multiple apps, they'll just go back to SMS default app.

Just use Johann's fork with SMS support and no APK expiration and don't update it. This would either buy you some months before proper alternative will be introduced or at best work infinitely.

https://github.com/johanw666/Signal-Android/releases

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#412

Am I in a bubble and these features are, in fact, widely used on WhatsApp? I'm in groups with a whole lot of other people including a few who keep up with modern social media stuff, use TikTok, use Instagram, et c., and zero of them use the Status feature or Stories or anything but messaging. For us it's just ICQ/text with better media embedding (but still really bad, somehow). Some of us regularly use similar featur…

By my experience only people in poor countries outside Europe use this feature. Don't ask me why this specific group chose this instead of Facebook/Instagram. Literally none Europeans from various countries in my Whatsapp use this.

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#413

Anyone know of a fork of signal that disables this keeps the SMS feature?

Dunno about stories, but Johann's fork has no APK expiration, so just keep version with SMS support prior stories added and you should be fine.

https://github.com/johanw666/Signal-Android/releases

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#415
The announcement says “give the people what they want”. You know what I really want in Signal for iOS? Backups, not stories. Congratulations for launching stories, but I honestly don’t understand why it has been prioritized over backups (E2E encrypted of course). That’s a major missing piece to replace WhatsApp and other messaging solutions.

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#416
post #399

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I imagine it's a lot of hassle to maintain and outside of the US SMS is basically as dead as landline phones. They probably consulted their usage statistics when they made that decision.

Why do people keep spreading these lies about SMS being dead outside the US?

Probably because it is dead in a large number of places (e.g. I haven't used SMS in the last 10 years for anything except these automated things that sometimes are sent), and people tend to generalize that to "outside the US".

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#417

That's cool but everyone in my family that I convinced to use Signal just stopped using it because it was their default SMS app. Now it's not.

Who uses SMS? I am always surprised when this feature is being mentioned.

Americans basically.

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#418
post #307
post #204

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think that's called Matrix and we already have that. Anyway, good luck getting Signal to federate with you until you have enough of a user base that they're losing users to your backend. They have zero reason to want to do this, and it introduces some privacy issues (what if your server doesn't respect deletions, etc?).

We even had it long before that. It's called XMPP, it's the internet standard for instant messaging and modern clients implement Signal style encryption.

Signal is just XMPP implementing the Axolotl ratchet.

XMPP is just SMTP and some protocol addons on top. SMTP is just FTP with RFC 469 and others. Etc.

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#419
post #405

Don't care. They can paint that thing in whatever color they want. I'm still not using a messenger with an algorithm developed next door to the NSA headquarters.

Not sure I understand. My impression was that the end-to-end encryption algorithm was probably the most secure thing about Signal, allowing strong encryption between sender and recipient without relying on trust of the central server. Regardless of where or how it was developed, it's open-source.

99.9% of the algorithms are open source, that is still no reason for them to be trusted since it takes years and years (sometimes decades) until exploits included by design are revealed: https://www.theverge.com/2013/9/11/4718694/how-far-did-the-n...

Trivia: What percentage of open source end-to-end encryption algorithms were developed by coincidence next door to the NSA headquarters?

Re: Signal Introduces Stories

#420

The announcement says “give the people what they want”. You know what I really want in Signal for iOS? Backups, not stories. Congratulations for launching stories, but I honestly don’t understand why it has been prioritized over backups (E2E encrypted of course). That’s a major missing piece to replace WhatsApp and other messaging solutions.

All I want is a way to quickly delete media per chat without needing to select every image and video manually.
Post reply on HN