Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: I will become a father tomorrow, what advice could you share with me?

news.ycombinator.com

121–130 of 156 posts

Re: Ask HN: I will become a father tomorrow, what advice could you share with me?

#121

All those books on parenting you have? Read them before the birth, because after it, you will have zero time and energy to do so.

My son is 4th month old and I still have plants of time for doing things (in the first month from his birth I managed to read 3 books… and do plenty of other things). It’s 2 adults and one baby… not that hard!

Re: Ask HN: I will become a father tomorrow, what advice could you share with me?

#122

Don't circumcise (genital mutilate) your kid if he's a boy.

Notice that the single bit of medical advice in this thread - among the tens of medical decisions you'll have to make and literally thousands of decisions you hope to not need to make - relates to religious aspects. And I'm sure that the guy who posted it was well-meaning, without a hint of religious hate in his blood. This is a terrific example of the "useful idiot" phenomenon. Those who hate any group - be it Jews…

The move to ban circumcision is picking up.

You should be honest about this. This wasn't really a "race" thing. You *wanted* to do this to your son. You did this without his consent. And you did something that is completely irreversible.

Don't compare this to fishing, riding a bike, or even using a knife. All of those are necessary skills, or at the very least, useful skills for children to know.

You did something that *was actually risky to do*, for literally no other reason other than this awful justification about "race".

And for what its worth, I'm Iranian. So I get how _expected_ it is from culture.

Re: Ask HN: I will become a father tomorrow, what advice could you share with me?

#123
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They most likely ignored the high-risk one (assuming FGM), because it is unthinkable of and is not even legal to perform in most western countries. Is it even a thing outside of a few ultra-conservative and religious countries/communities in Africa and Middle East?

> because it is unthinkable In that case the "if its a boy" clause was unnecessary. Consider the following sentence: > If you are pregnant then you shouldn't smoke if you're a woman.

The message was obvious by everyone reading this post.

Re: Ask HN: I will become a father tomorrow, what advice could you share with me?

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> There is absolutely no medical reason to do this Phimosis, Fournier's gangrene, and potentially permanent deformation of the glans.

A person can get circumcised when (if) those things happen. There's no medical reason for indiscriminate circumcision at birth .

The same could be said of any post-natal surgery for congenital birth defects, such as club foot or cleft lip. Many can go without surgery and live their entire lives without developing early-onset arthritis or feeding issues. These days, and in the vast majority of cases, a person can live a relatively healthy and long life without surgery for congenital arrhythmia. But I have never heard or read wholesale condemnations of preventive infant surgery to mitigate, if not prevent, the outcomes of the aforementioned defects. In fact, the opposite is true; Someone (usually a parent or doctor) is expected to do something at the earliest possible moment, even if the issue left untreated would only have a negligible chance of getting "worse" in terms of health or otherwise.

I agree that there's no medical reason for indiscriminate circumcision at birth, or, for that matter, indiscriminate surgery of any kind at any time. After all, that's what circumcision is: surgery. However, the poster I responded to did not make that distinction. Another poster simply posted the word "propaganda". Given what I've read, I'm convinced that many of these anti-circumcision posts are motivated by animus — whether of genital surgery in its entirety or the religious elements associated with it — rather than a well-thought critique of the practice in secular and instrumental terms.

A wholesale dismissal of circumcision is as unthinking as a blind acceptance of it. Instead, each case must be assessed on its own merits. Unfortunately, I rarely see my particular position shared by anyone else.

Re: Ask HN: I will become a father tomorrow, what advice could you share with me?

#127
post #14

Some practical things I’ve learned after a year: 1. Pace yourself. You’re going to want to try to do as much as you can with your newborn/infant but sometimes they’re just not ready for it. If you try to be very extra with your child on day one, you’re going to burn yourself out. A corollary is to appreciate the free time you get. 2. Children all develop in their own way so don’t freak out if your experience somethin…

On point 4, be aware of potential risks with Baby Brezza: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/13/technology/baby-brezza-fo...

Re: Ask HN: I will become a father tomorrow, what advice could you share with me?

#130
You're going to lose out on some things, especially time. Time and mental energy. It's easy, in the middle of the very real losses, to look at the losses and not see the gains. You can have some really cool relationships and a lot of fun, but you'll miss it if you focus on what you're losing. You'll lose out, and so will your kids. Don't do that. It's one of my biggest regrets. I was too focused on what I wanted to do and think, and trying to find time to do it in (and brain cells to do it with), that I kind of missed my kids.

And, um, don't assume that it will be tomorrow, even if they're inducing. That can take more than a day sometimes.

Post reply on HN