Live data from Hacker News

I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

akselmo.dev

41–50 of 114 posts

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#41
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While we're at it, Windows 10 suffers the same problem.

Both Win10 and Win11 will draw outline using accent color if you enable "Show accent color on title bars and windows borders". There are also tools to configure it further.

Thanks for this tip, it worked on Windows 11. On Windows 10 where I had already enabled it it's a near invisible 1 pixel border.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#42

It’s always nice to read about someone contributing to open source. Looking at the screenshots I have a question for the KDE users here. I am surprised by the incorrect kerning and strange padding on display in the interface. Is that normal or is it a consequence of it being so customisable the author likes settings which leads to this result?

I can't speak to the kerning (it looks fine to me, I guess I'm not a font nerd) but in those screenshots, the user has selected monochrome subpixel rendering and either no or very light hinting. These together make the text a bit more blurry than it does on my own machine.

And of course, it's also possible that using a better font would improve things.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#44

I have a visual impairment that make it really hard for me to distinguish objects where the is little contrast. This new UI trend of one pixel borders is a big annoyance for me. I constantly click the wrong window. I actually wrote a Windows app to do something like this. It's sitting in my unfinished folder because I ran into too many issues to fix for a hobby project. The rectangle data for Windows apps seems to va…

Microsoft Windows is abysmal on this front - I have to use Microsoft Windows 10 periodically, while most of my life is spent in KDE, and the disjoint is jarring.

In KDE I can precisely control and set window border thickness and colour.

In Microsoft Windows 10 (and I assume 11 has continued the trend at making this even worse) I can enable a very thin border, of a themed colour, and that border disappears when the window is no longer in focus. This means a couple of terminal windows (eg gitbash) have near impossible to discern edges when they're overlapping.

On top of this, some Microsoft applications seem to break their own styling rules (Office apps, say) which I suspect is the kind of issue that stalled your project.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#45

I haven't touched KDE in maybe 15 years. I just always defaulted to Gnome when I'm on Linux desktop. But this looks more macOS like. Just curious, is there any reason I should try KDE today?

I've always had a soft spot for KDE but haven't actually used it much in the last decade because I kept running into show-stopping bugs.

But this week I decided to try out the latest KDE plasma release on Debian testing and it's all going quite well so far. I love having the ability to configure things how _I_ want them to be, while adhering to a more traditional desktop experience.

The easiest way to try out the latest KDE release is to download Neon (https://neon.kde.org), flash it to a thumb drive, and boot it up.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#46
post #44

I have a visual impairment that make it really hard for me to distinguish objects where the is little contrast. This new UI trend of one pixel borders is a big annoyance for me. I constantly click the wrong window. I actually wrote a Windows app to do something like this. It's sitting in my unfinished folder because I ran into too many issues to fix for a hobby project. The rectangle data for Windows apps seems to va…

Microsoft Windows is abysmal on this front - I have to use Microsoft Windows 10 periodically, while most of my life is spent in KDE, and the disjoint is jarring. In KDE I can precisely control and set window border thickness and colour. In Microsoft Windows 10 (and I assume 11 has continued the trend at making this even worse) I can enable a very thin border, of a themed colour, and that border disappears when the wi…

Yeah, I recently started to use KDE Plasma with Fedora (after Gnome left a sour taste), and the amount of customizations it allows is mind-blowing. This may be common knowledge, but as a newcomer to KDE, these very precise controls are quite a fresh breath from OSs like Win10/11 and Mac OS.

Reminded me of those Windows 98 shell customizations. Windows seems to be going backwards when it comes to customizations; there are only a few customizations allowed in Windows 11 now.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#48

I haven't touched KDE in maybe 15 years. I just always defaulted to Gnome when I'm on Linux desktop. But this looks more macOS like. Just curious, is there any reason I should try KDE today?

Modern KDE is closer to the experience and usability of GNOME 2 than GNOME 3 is. (And that’s a good thing.) If you prefer a traditional desktop with some configurability over iOS, it’s worth a try.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#49
This is nice. One of the reasons I still stick to the "Plastik" style and haven't moved to Breeze is the "smoothness" of the interface. This seems to bring in some definition to the interface.

I know plastik feels so old and out of date. But it feels more tactile to me because of the higher gradients.

Re: I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration

#50
I'm glad that windows have outlines, but I'm still disappointed KDE has switched both foreground and background windows to light titlebars by default. This is something I change out of the box on both Windows 10 (dark gray accent color for title bar) and KDE (Breeze Classic color scheme).
Post reply on HN