Live data from Hacker News

Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

bbc.com

111–120 of 121 posts

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#111

According to [1], he didn't wash in water, but with Fire instead: "He would reject water in favour of what he called a “fire bath”. “Every evening as villagers gather, Kalau … lights a bonfire, smokes marijuana and stands on a leg praying to Lord Shiva,” the paper said." [1] - https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/25/worlds-dirties...

That's referring to an Indian man, not this individual. Interesting story nonetheless.

My mistake, thanks for the correction!

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

yeah, I wonder what religion was this Iranian guy, doesn't seem like very good believer

I don't know if your comment is being serious or snarky, but have you looked at his heart to judge his belief?

well he clearly didn't do this ritual and as Iranian he is very likely Muslim, so...

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know if your comment is being serious or snarky, but have you looked at his heart to judge his belief?

well he clearly didn't do this ritual and as Iranian he is very likely Muslim, so...

Well, it's not a black-or-white thing where you can label a person as either "bad" or "good" based on your perception of one of his actions.

If he was a Muslim, then yes, he maybe was not practicing, and that would be considered a sin. But you can't deduce anything from that about his fate or whether is was a "bad believer". Why? For a number of reasons:

- From a religious perspective, God charges no soul beyond its capacity, that is, what it is capable of bearing. We know nothing about the guy. What circumstances lead him to this lifestyle? Was he trapped? In the islamic view, actions are but by intentions. Do we know anything about his intentions? Only God knows.

- Also from a religous perspective, there is no perfect human, we are all sinful. Good deeds balance bad ones. One of the stories in the islamic texts is that of a prostitute who saw a thirsty dog, took off her shoe and watered it, and god forgave her because of that good deed.

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had a 40 year old car that was rarely serviced but ran like a champ. I moved across country and the new mechanic told me I should use some cleansing agent to de-gunk all of the various hoses/manifolds/whatever in the engine. It seemed expensive so I went for to a second mechanic and mentioned it, and he was adamant that I not do it, and that all that gunk was what was sealing the hoses and letting the car operate.…

You're talking about a car and you have no idea what happened to it.

No need to be rude. He’s making an analogy based on the parent comment and an experience he had.

It’s a good story.

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#115
post #72

An anecdote: A reporter interviews an old highlander at his home: - What's your secret? How did you manage to live for so long? - For all my life I've followed three simple rules: no alcohol, no tobacco and no women! Suddenly they hear some noise behind the wall in the other room. - What's that? - asks the reporter. - Oh, that's my elder brother. He's drunk again and is beating his wives for hiding his cigarettes.

How this typically plays out, AFAIK, is that the interviewee's brother would be the second oldest person in the area. In a town behind the hill, there lives the oldest person in the region - a woman that's over 100 years old. Her secret? The place doesn't do birth certificates, and she took over the identity of her mother once the latter passed away.

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#116

I stopped using soap a decade ago. The only time I use it now is for rare occasions where I get something on me that requires soap, such as motor oil or chemicals. I also only wash twice a week or so. People always recoil when I tell them, but then I ask them what I smell like to them. They say I don't really smell like anything. The first month was the worst, because my skin took time to adjust to not having its oil…

Soap isn't what gets things clean, anyway, water does. Soap merely lowers water surface tension, and making water molecules stick together less helps water clean more easily.

To add a data point here...I've read studies on the effectiveness of handwashing for sterilization. Apparently it's simply the abrasion under water that removes pathogens from the skin. Studies found no difference in effectiveness of just water versus water+soap.

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#117

I stopped using soap a decade ago. The only time I use it now is for rare occasions where I get something on me that requires soap, such as motor oil or chemicals. I also only wash twice a week or so. People always recoil when I tell them, but then I ask them what I smell like to them. They say I don't really smell like anything. The first month was the worst, because my skin took time to adjust to not having its oil…

I've read testimonials from women who had severe acne and cured the problem by stopping frequent washing of the face with soap. It that case, the restriction of soap usage clearly improved skin health.

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

well he clearly didn't do this ritual and as Iranian he is very likely Muslim, so...

Well, it's not a black-or-white thing where you can label a person as either "bad" or "good" based on your perception of one of his actions. If he was a Muslim, then yes, he maybe was not practicing, and that would be considered a sin. But you can't deduce anything from that about his fate or whether is was a "bad believer". Why? For a number of reasons: - From a religious perspective, God charges no soul beyond its…

> doesn't seem like very good believer

Don't twist my words, only one writing here - he is bad - is you. It's like I will say about someone getting only Bs they are not very good student and you will argue I am saying they are bad student.

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#119
post #6

Ugh I love ads that take up half the screen and you can't click away from

Don't know how you live without an ad blocker.

There are a lot of people on this site who work in adtech, so don't run an ad blocker

I have to respect the willingness to self-flagellate

Re: Iranian man who didn't wash for half a century dies at 94

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've lived all over the place, from dry to wet-towel-in-your-face humid, from -25c to 45c. Even after an hour long workout dripping with sweat I don't really smell like anything. The way to test your own body odor without asking other people is to take a deep whiff of yesterday's shirt when you wake up in the morning. Even better would be to walk around outside a bit before you smell your old shirt in order to keep a…

or you could just ask your own (young) kids, they have no filter, sometimes when we lay in bed they tell me I stink, they mean armpits, not that it would be necessary, even I can smell it at that point if I try

Strong smells also can be associated to pleasant things. If your grampa smelled weird, but you loved him, you'll love the weird smell too after a while.
Post reply on HN