Live data from Hacker News

Replit Mobile App

blog.replit.com

191–200 of 212 posts

Re: Replit Mobile App

#191

This is one of those examples for me where the idea is far superior than the implementation. The idea of anyone being able to quickly write code from anywhere, as the main promo video suggests, is fantastic and greatly motivating. In practice, coding on an iPhone (even with an innovative new joystick), is gimmicky at best, given how deeply ingrained good ergonomics are in the coding process. I struggle to see this as…

I work on iSH, which is in a similar product area. The thing is that by all intents and purposes the environment we give you is terrible: you have a software keyboard, and navigating around and typing is pretty bad. But we have plenty of users who love it and use it really heavily. Why? A lot are children who have phones but can’t always access a computer. Some people want to code on the go. They’re really doing it out of necessity when they don’t have another device, not because the experience we provide is good. There’s definitely room for improvement but I doubt using a phone will ever be as pleasant as using a computer. And that’s fine.

Re: Replit Mobile App

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

None of these are particularly unique ideas. There could easily be multiple products which all do these and work in very different ways. You are asking why the CEO of a company is not deeply engaged with your ideas and didn't invest in them. The simple answer is that you didn't present them well and he probably doesn't have time to dig into them deeply. I really doubt he did a teardown on your projects and then stole…

Further discussion is pointless. I gave enough facts... And all other algorithms are known. Usually technical people communicate and not brazenly copy other people's ideas, as happened 4k HN topic or rr debugger Amjad startup fact. Let me remind you that he presented himself as "an investor" and was not even interested in the most complex technology in the world, but preferred to simply make a clone I will remind you…

It’s not clear what your story has to do with anything?

Re: Replit Mobile App

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Okay... Did you read my link post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33267464 ? 1) No. I'm not dumb and programming language author, CTO, polygot, architect, old school, and make better software all my life. I made the world's first mobile IDE and real-time reverse debugger 2) No. 4k likes HN post shows the opposite. I asked Amjad for help while COVID-19 because no job, no money, don't know what to do and this peop…

sorry but I think the features you listed as being stolen seem pretty generic. For example "mobile IDE (ipad pro with keyboard)" doesn't tell me what specific IDE features you'd implement. In this case, Replit made the "joystick" feature. Same with "team development and other features". Also it seems you're blaming Amjad for your project being delayed? Not sure how that is related.

And, to be fair, even UI features like the joystick aren’t that big of a feature. We’ve had a similar thing in our app for years, it’s cropped up in several others over time including here. In the long run nobody is using our app because we did a joystick thing before Replit did.

Re: Replit Mobile App

#194
post #113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm, generally, not bullish: But only because the predominating "what value do products like this bring" arguments from those who are bullish is some variation of "it's great for learning/beginners". That's simply no way to build a venture business (and replit has received... $105M). Higher layers of abstraction can make sense; no code tools can be killer; but that isn't really replit. Replit is just a weird product…

Just my take, but the more people who can “code”, even at a basic level, the better. Because then they intuit that the challenging part in not the words but the logic. Learn to code then be an “excel jockey”. Those folks create just as much value with less of the identity bullshit. Edit - sorry if this sounded confrontational. That wasn’t my intent - I just learned that I feel passionately about this topic.

Excel certainly has it's place and is great as an interchange format and prototyping platform for domain specialists. I agree that it's unjustly derided by snobbish programmers. Converting to and from CSV is cheaply implemented and can do wonder as human interface to a system since "non programmers" know how to deal with that.

The problems start when it is pushed beyond its limits, sheets can become undocumented mess of cell spaghetti which users still expect to scale up and grow new features indefinitely. It's hard to determine for Excel coders when they are past that cost/benefit tipover point and move up to a more robust set of programming tools.

Re: Replit Mobile App

#196
post #4

Presently on iOS it appears this is an iPhone app that doesn't scale to iPad screen dimensions, even when expanded. It's using between a third and a half of the available viewport in landscape orientation. That said, it appears to work pretty well in side-by-side mode, concurrently with another app, but it still uses about half the available viewport in this mode. I expect this will get addressed PDQ.

It might be interesting to try out the CodeSandbox app: https://apps.apple.com/nl/app/codesandbox/id1423330822?l=e.

It's the same concept, you get a VM you can work on from a native app, but our app is for iOS only and supports iPads natively.

Disclaimer: I'm one of the co-founders of CodeSandbox.

Re: Replit Mobile App

#197
post #13

I've been programming on my phone with termux + vim. It's been sort of a delight.

The thought of using vim on a phone gives me mild anxiety but I'll definitely check termux!

It works quite well. There is a lack of precision trying to drag the cursor around on Android, which is made worse on the <$100 quality devices. Using vim's keyboard commands, I can precisely edit text far easier than anything else I have used on a phone. I never used emacs because I'm not a fan of chords, and this is amplified on the phone. However, people who swipe text may like emacs chords over vim's commands and modes.

Re: Replit Mobile App

#198
post #26

I'm bullish on this because mobile (and web) development is ridiculously overcomplicated to a beginner. I think it's a common misconception that coding/logic is difficult. I find the development setup and deployment to be much more complicated. As evidence, take a look at the impressive workarounds that citizen developers use to make things work in an easy environment like Excel. A keyboard and mouse probably solve m…

This is it for me. My background is in design so I'm a novice when it comes to any development. But setting things up via command line confuses me to hell.

Re: Replit Mobile App

#199
I worked in Haiti for 4 years. Very few Haitians had a desktop computer. Some had laptops, but they were uncommon. But, everybody has a cellphone. The last time I went, I saw Andriod internet capable phones all over the place. I believe it's the same in many other parts of the world. This could be hugely useful and popular for people outside the typical tech industry pipelines. Commenters are underestimating the ingenuity of folks in those areas.
Post reply on HN