Live data from Hacker News

Privacy respecting weather app for Android

f-droid.org

21–30 of 99 posts

Re: Privacy respecting weather app for Android

#21
post #4

The developers [0] of this app have a whole series of different Privacy Friendly Apps, if you search for "org.secuso" on f-droid you can see them all. [0] https://secuso.aifb.kit.edu/index.php

This is brilliant, there's some apps in that collection I was going to try and create myself with dart/flutter.

Probably still will for learning but thanks.

Re: Privacy respecting weather app for Android

#22
post #18

The fact that it had to be mentioned at all for a weather app is concerning & telling of the state of tech

Privacy in good weather apps that are innovative can be tricky. Phones have enough sensors like barometers to be useful weather stations, and collecting that data could improve forecasts. But that also includes accurate location data, and making a useful forecast model from data collected on device is significantly more challenging when you account for privacy needs. The “telling state of tech” may be that our hardwa…

Sure, but I'm fine with sharing my data for that purpose. I also have an app that registers any possible earthquakes and shares that data with a centralized server for analysis. I'm perfectly fine with that, as long as they don't sell my data to anyone who wants to market earthquake safety equipment or wants to track my location.

Transparency on the use of data is important to make decisions on this type of stuff. If a weather app requests access to my barometer to improve predictions, independent of my personal data, I would fully comply with that.

Re: Privacy respecting weather app for Android

#23
post #4

The developers [0] of this app have a whole series of different Privacy Friendly Apps, if you search for "org.secuso" on f-droid you can see them all. [0] https://secuso.aifb.kit.edu/index.php

That's pretty awesome. The page with an overview of all their apps is right here:

https://secuso.aifb.kit.edu/english/105.php

Re: Privacy respecting weather app for Android

#24
I really like Rain Alarm (https://app.rain-alarm.com/). They do collect data, but they are very explicit about what they collect, how it is treated, and when it is removed. Even if you don't want to use it due to personal reasons, you have to respect them putting this info right at the forefront, as most try to hide it.

Also, I didn't even realize until now, but the app's functionality is available via the web (https://rain-alarm.com/).

Re: Privacy respecting weather app for Android

#28
post #19

The fact that it had to be mentioned at all for a weather app is concerning & telling of the state of tech

Indeed. That's why I like the privacy cards on the iOS App Store a lot. For apps like this, it makes it really easy to spot the ones that'll record my location data on their servers for some reason. It's the same with fitness tracking apps, so many of them send health data to their servers, but there are a few (often paid ones, of course) that seem to store important data only locally.

>That's why I like the privacy cards on the iOS App Store a lot

Donkeyd, I find the privacy cards in the iOS app store to be an unreliable source. I will read the relevant privacy policy stating 'data not collected' to mean anything but. Do you know if the card self-reporting?

Re: Privacy respecting weather app for Android

#29
post #19

The fact that it had to be mentioned at all for a weather app is concerning & telling of the state of tech

Indeed. That's why I like the privacy cards on the iOS App Store a lot. For apps like this, it makes it really easy to spot the ones that'll record my location data on their servers for some reason. It's the same with fitness tracking apps, so many of them send health data to their servers, but there are a few (often paid ones, of course) that seem to store important data only locally.

Can you name a few, please?

I am very reluctant to fitness apps and devices for that exact reason and I'd really like to see a privacy friendly app.

Bonus points if you know devices that can be used with local data only.

Re: Privacy respecting weather app for Android

#30
post #22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Privacy in good weather apps that are innovative can be tricky. Phones have enough sensors like barometers to be useful weather stations, and collecting that data could improve forecasts. But that also includes accurate location data, and making a useful forecast model from data collected on device is significantly more challenging when you account for privacy needs. The “telling state of tech” may be that our hardwa…

Sure, but I'm fine with sharing my data for that purpose. I also have an app that registers any possible earthquakes and shares that data with a centralized server for analysis. I'm perfectly fine with that, as long as they don't sell my data to anyone who wants to market earthquake safety equipment or wants to track my location. Transparency on the use of data is important to make decisions on this type of stuff. If…

They may not sell your data, but it might be subpoenaed by a court. Or breached by a hacker. Or leaked by a coding error. Or by incorrect AWS permissions. Or an email campaign by a stupid PM.
Post reply on HN