Live data from Hacker News

Project Starline expands testing through an early access program

blog.google

11–20 of 151 posts

Re: Project Starline expands testing through an early access program

#11
post #4

Quoted post unavailable.

My perspective is that if it doesn't serve ads it likely doesn't have a future at Google.

I would be interested in playing around with this tech, but I wouldn't integrate it into my business or any other part of my life.

Re: Project Starline expands testing through an early access program

#12

I have definitely been wrong about technology before, prime example was camera phones when the first appeared; couldn't for the life of me see the point. With that caveat, I don't get how this makes employees/customers/clients more engaged/productive or form rapport/have better experiences. Like the Facebook thing I'm definitely not using anything that has to be this massively invasive (eye tracking, facial recogniti…

The desire to connect across distance is very real. Grandparents want to see their grandkids, customers want to see their vendors, friends want to see each other.

Re: Project Starline expands testing through an early access program

#15
post #10

I'm struggling to believe Google will see this through beyond a tech demo. And who's the target audience? I mean, what would a unit's cost be? Looks like another cool tech Google won't be able to productize successfully. Edit: I was super excited for Soli way back when, but so far haven't see any smart clothes they were imagining in the early days.

Soli did seem cool. Wasn't Jacquard the smart clothing technology? Surprisingly, I think there are some products: https://atap.google.com/jacquard/products/

I couldn't find either jackets for sale (broken links), and the promo videos were rather underwhelming. Seems like a smart watch can already do all of these, albeit in a less "cool" manner, and it's not tied to a piece of clothing. I was imagining something more cyberpunk, and not just an input device. Perhaps, that goes beyond what Soli tries to achieve.

Edit: I can imagine more interesting use cases where you can't use precise input, for example when wearing gloves (construction, space suite, etc.).

Re: Project Starline expands testing through an early access program

#16

This is my favorite Google project. I hope it becomes something that we all can use. To me, at least, this is more useful than meeting in vr with no legs.

My questions are:

1. Does it only support 1-on-1 meetings (the demos only show 1-1)? I think that's still useful, but note probably 90%+ of my online meetings have at least 3 people.

2. Sounds like the expense means it will only be installed in offices, not people's homes. Which, again, is still useful as long as it hits the 3rd bullet point.

3. Does everyone need to be on a Starline device to participate? I'd expect/hope to get "graceful degredation" in functionality for folks who were just joining from, say, their laptop at home.

Re: Project Starline expands testing through an early access program

#17

This is my favorite Google project. I hope it becomes something that we all can use. To me, at least, this is more useful than meeting in vr with no legs.

I think the legs thing is overblown. No legs is better than uncanny valley legs.

Re: Project Starline expands testing through an early access program

#19
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not a very high bar there

The point being competitors are pouring billions into VR meetings, but this project at google is getting little attention.

Google R&D projects don't have the longevity reputation, so they might not deserve attention.
Post reply on HN