Live data from Hacker News

Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

adhdevidence.org

61–70 of 114 posts

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#61
post #27
post #5

I have a feeling that the massive quantities of prescribed amphetamines we've dumped into the population, including millions of children, is going to age about as well as using radium for wristwatches. But I guess we'll have to see the "evidence" for that.

In situations where there is a dopamine deficiency, stimulants like amphetamines counterintuitively have the opposite effect than you would expect.

What you say is true but doesn't necessarily contradict gp. Although stimulants work, they have unpleasant side effects and I hope one day we discover a better solution.

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#62
post #48

What a garbage site, in so many dimensions. I really enjoyed how the first answer to the question of how people with ADHD can improve their lives is, "take your meds!"

Getting prescribed meds was the single biggest game changer so that makes sense to me…though I guess everyone is different.

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#63
post #4

I can't believe they're making a site for individuals with ADHD that uses that many carousels.

I listen to a few ADHD podcasts and one of them has the most annoying loud music in the background during commercials as if they're just asking you to skip. It's even more grating if you listen at 3x speed.

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Funnily enough, ADDitude is a decent online magazine with some insightful articles- it's the first place I discovered the concept of RSD in detail- but it also falls prey to the content marketing school of web design.

Is RSD as a common trait of ADHD actually backed by evidence, or is it just one doctor's theory?

No idea, but this was an interesting podcast episode. I recall they do mention at some point about how ADHD in general is physically detectable by doing brain scans and seeing what areas light up?

https://additudemag.libsyn.com/278-the-flip-side-of-rejectio...

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#65
post #60
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you cite sources that CBT was inspired by NLP? They have similarities, but CBT is evidence-based and NLP is not.

I'd say the two fields are very different. In the case of NLP - they watched very successful therapists in the 1970s, noticed some common themes, and extracted out a model. So for example, Milton Erickson would tell artfully vague stories to his clients, which were clever metaphors for healing, tailored to the individual. It's difficult to run scientific experiments to prove the efficacy of this - it depends on the s…

Oh, to be fair, NLP proposed the meta model, which was based on how Virginia Satir would solve people's problems by just getting them to be more specific, in a skilful way. This would highlight how our thinking can change how we experience things, through what they called deletions, generalisations and distortions.

CBT does something very similar with how it focuses on making language more realistic and less emotive.

So there are similarities in that sense.

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#66
post #5

I have a feeling that the massive quantities of prescribed amphetamines we've dumped into the population, including millions of children, is going to age about as well as using radium for wristwatches. But I guess we'll have to see the "evidence" for that.

Shhh, you're not supposed to acknowledge that having a large fraction of tech workers hopped up on goofballs is more about their economic output than their health.

Is it goofballs or is it microdosing acid? I'm not sure what the lurid tech tabloid tale of the week is.

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#67

I remain highly skeptical that there is a common neurological physical pathology in children that is treatable by a steady lifetime use of amphetamines and amphetamine derivatives. It's all comparable to the other major pharamceutical scandal of our era, i.e. the opiate prescription business. I would agree that children who appear incapable of paying attention to their teachers (who may not be very good teachers) in…

Undiagnosed and untreated adults with ADHD develop higher than normal rates of mental illness like anxiety and depression, higher rates of substance abuse and addiction, and often have difficulty maintaining personal relationships, careers, even basic personal responsibilities. Whatever the physiological reason, failing to diagnose and treat ADHD has a detrimental effect for many of us.

I was diagnosed a few years ago, after a fairly severe mental health crisis with crippling anxiety and nearly drinking myself to death. Since diagnosis and beginning treatment with stimulants, I’ve been able to put my life back together. My life is stable, I’m happier than I ever was even before my mental health tanked, and my anxiety is manageable enough I seldom take notice of it.

I don’t like the side effects of stimulants, particularly the toll they've taken on my already poor dental health (for folks who don’t know, “meth mouth” can be a thing even with prescription amphetamines taken as prescribed, not just from smoking). But I have no doubt in my mind that whatever side effects I’ve experienced or may, it’s better by far than what I’d have experienced without meds.

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#68
post #57

> This information War on ADHD stigmatizes affected people, On the contrary I see tons of accommodations made by both private and public organizations. Many, many people seem to enjoy diagnosing themselves with this condition. Can someone point to evidence of stigmatization?

Getting meds at the pharmacy (even after getting a prescription) can be a pain. I’ve run into issues where I’ll have a prescription, but the pharmacy that it’s sent to is out of stock. But pharmacy’s aren’t allowed to disclose stock of controlled substances over the phone, so I have to call my Dr to ask them to transfer the prescription to a different pharmacy, hoping that it’s not out of stock. If it is, I have to do that all over again. It’s annoying to say the least.

Re: Evidence-based conclusions about ADHD

#69
post #68
post #57

> This information War on ADHD stigmatizes affected people, On the contrary I see tons of accommodations made by both private and public organizations. Many, many people seem to enjoy diagnosing themselves with this condition. Can someone point to evidence of stigmatization?

Getting meds at the pharmacy (even after getting a prescription) can be a pain. I’ve run into issues where I’ll have a prescription, but the pharmacy that it’s sent to is out of stock. But pharmacy’s aren’t allowed to disclose stock of controlled substances over the phone, so I have to call my Dr to ask them to transfer the prescription to a different pharmacy, hoping that it’s not out of stock. If it is, I have to d…

I think maybe you answered the wrong comment
Post reply on HN