Live data from Hacker News

Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

github.com

111–120 of 262 posts

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#111

After Netflix and others streaming services, I stop using Transmission. What’s the current usage of BitTorrent?

For me a lot of streaming services have simple stopped working(Amazon Prime) in Firefox or are limited to 720p(Netflix), even though I have the DRM stuff enabled in Firefox. So I use it to be able to stream my "Debian ISOs" in at least full HD.

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#112
Good to see it being in active development. But the one feature I'm waiting for is a network whitelist. For example, it should never connect over my home or office network, but only via anonymous VPN.

(Edit: I know you can do this already with firewall rules, or containers, but I don't trust myself to not make a mistake. Ideally this should be part of the OS. You should be able to right-click somewhere in the window and say "use this network for this app".)

The other feature I'd like to see is sequential downloads, but the developers object out of principle so that is never going to come.

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#113

Good to see it being in active development. But the one feature I'm waiting for is a network whitelist. For example, it should never connect over my home or office network, but only via anonymous VPN. (Edit: I know you can do this already with firewall rules, or containers, but I don't trust myself to not make a mistake. Ideally this should be part of the OS. You should be able to right-click somewhere in the window…

I have to agree with them, it’s antithetical to what torrent is about.

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#114

Good to see it being in active development. But the one feature I'm waiting for is a network whitelist. For example, it should never connect over my home or office network, but only via anonymous VPN. (Edit: I know you can do this already with firewall rules, or containers, but I don't trust myself to not make a mistake. Ideally this should be part of the OS. You should be able to right-click somewhere in the window…

I'm using namespaced-openvpn to restrict transmission to one network and you could limit the amount of concurrently active files to one, effectively downloading them sequentially. Or do you want to download each file sequentially?

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#115

Good to see it being in active development. But the one feature I'm waiting for is a network whitelist. For example, it should never connect over my home or office network, but only via anonymous VPN. (Edit: I know you can do this already with firewall rules, or containers, but I don't trust myself to not make a mistake. Ideally this should be part of the OS. You should be able to right-click somewhere in the window…

This is a plug-and-play solution bundling Transmission and the most common VPN configurations in a Docker container, ensuring that all torrent traffic goes via an active VPN connection. After configuring it, you just run "docker-compose up" and can then access Transmission via its web UI. It could be nice to have this built into the client, but using a container feels safer.

https://github.com/haugene/docker-transmission-openvpn

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#116

Good to see it being in active development. But the one feature I'm waiting for is a network whitelist. For example, it should never connect over my home or office network, but only via anonymous VPN. (Edit: I know you can do this already with firewall rules, or containers, but I don't trust myself to not make a mistake. Ideally this should be part of the OS. You should be able to right-click somewhere in the window…

I run my torrent client in a container and have that container only go out the vpn. Works very well without screwing with computer wide network settings.

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#117
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Write it on their github maybe? Also I would be interested, how many people there use a VPN for torrents?

There are already GitHub issues like this. The maintainers simply close them.

As is their right and somehow even their duty if it is not in alignment with the project's philosophy or goals.

You can create a fork and implement the feature or pay someone to implement it for you. That's the wonderful benefit of free software.

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#118
post #91

I'm really excited to see support for torrents v2. If only because transmission will stop chocking on hybrid torrent files, which should lead to more adoption across the board. I wish transmission supported mutable torrents (BEP46). It would allow completely re-thinking distribution: grab a torrent of your favorite distribution, and have it auto-update to the latest version. Or grab a "super-torrent" that lists isos…

First it needs to support BEP44 "Mutable DHT", which is arguably a much more useful feature than mutable torrents. It is also a much simpler feature.

http://www.bittorrent.org/beps/bep_0044.html

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#119
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For example, buying a 4K HDR movie on iTunes does not allow you to even cache it locally ( https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251320670 ), it is 100% streamed meaning you have to have a very sizeable and stable internet connection to watch it uninterrupted. Downloading it from a side channel means you can buy it on your favourite platform and actually keep it on your computer.

> Downloading it from a side channel means you can buy it on your favourite platform and actually keep it on your computer. That would give the distribution platform the idea that what they are doing is OK. In this case, just download it and don't pay for it, if they are not actually providing you of any service. Vote with your wallet.

How are the producers reimbursed in your example?

Re: Transmission 4.0.0 beta 1

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Streaming services are increasingly going over cable TV route and screwing customers over. The age of piracy is back.

Please, don't call copyright infringement 'piracy'. Piracy is a penal crime that involves violence, theft of property and is often accompanied by murders. Torrenting is just copying data.

Even if the technical process is just "copying data" there is a whole world of legal and ethical issues around it.

Torrenting non-free products from unofficial sources is illegal.

Post reply on HN