Live data from Hacker News

What's the right age to get a smartphone?

bbc.com

31–40 of 44 posts

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#31

It depends. If your child age 12-16 years shows interest in programming. Purchase all the smartphones for them to learn to code. Or a raspberry pi.

A smartphone to learn how to code? Not sure if sarcastic....

I agree, but it's worth noting that scratch can be used on a phone. Wonder Workshop is an example.

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#32

I think as every year passes we get closer to a point where younger and younger kids need a cell phone. I grew up till about 12 without one, so I can quite distinctly remember a time without. And even then, I didn’t get a smartphone until like 14. “Mobile culture” didn’t really take off till my last 2 years in HS. A lot of being a kid nowadays involves interacting with others on these devices. But at the same time, w…

You had a phone with 12? And a smartphone with 14?

Wow crazy.

I bought my first Smartphone with 23.

I'm really really curious how this will and already affects lots of kids who don't have the skill set to learn by themselves how to handle it correctly.

I'm still waisting too much time with it.

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#35
One thing I'm considering is getting my kid a laptop when they start asking for a smartphone. They'll be able to engage socially for the most part, but it won't have the "with you every moment of every day" problem. And instead of a device that's mainly geared towards consumption, they'll at least have tool that's designed to to empower its user.

And it will run Linux! No kid of mine will grow up thinking proprietary software is normal! The source is yours to command!

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#36
post #35

One thing I'm considering is getting my kid a laptop when they start asking for a smartphone. They'll be able to engage socially for the most part, but it won't have the "with you every moment of every day" problem. And instead of a device that's mainly geared towards consumption, they'll at least have tool that's designed to to empower its user. And it will run Linux! No kid of mine will grow up thinking proprietary…

If they turn out not to be a programmer, won't using Linux hurt them? Basically every other profession/industry either use windows-only software, or have some kind of policy to use windows (microsoft intune, etc...)

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#37

I mine at 58 years old (this year). I'm not sure I'm mature enough for it. It's a clunky, yet seductive slab of glass, what with that persistent lure of connectivity to the world, and access to the sum of all human knowledge. More horsepower than the Cray, without the cooling, raised floor, maintenance or power bills, and yet the NSA doesn't object to me owning one myself... could it be the tracking it affords them?…

This sounds so much like a GPT-3 response....

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#38
post #36
post #35

One thing I'm considering is getting my kid a laptop when they start asking for a smartphone. They'll be able to engage socially for the most part, but it won't have the "with you every moment of every day" problem. And instead of a device that's mainly geared towards consumption, they'll at least have tool that's designed to to empower its user. And it will run Linux! No kid of mine will grow up thinking proprietary…

If they turn out not to be a programmer, won't using Linux hurt them? Basically every other profession/industry either use windows-only software, or have some kind of policy to use windows (microsoft intune, etc...)

It's not hard to learn the basics of another operating system, and it's something they're going to have to do no matter what. They'll be learning new software their whole lives. And how would using software that respects their privacy and agency hurt them? I don't particularly want to them to be software devs, I want to empower them to use tools to accomplish their goals, and Linux is great for that.

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#39
post #36
post #35

One thing I'm considering is getting my kid a laptop when they start asking for a smartphone. They'll be able to engage socially for the most part, but it won't have the "with you every moment of every day" problem. And instead of a device that's mainly geared towards consumption, they'll at least have tool that's designed to to empower its user. And it will run Linux! No kid of mine will grow up thinking proprietary…

If they turn out not to be a programmer, won't using Linux hurt them? Basically every other profession/industry either use windows-only software, or have some kind of policy to use windows (microsoft intune, etc...)

If they can type out any linux command, it should be no problem for them to hit a few buttons in windows.

Re: What's the right age to get a smartphone?

#40
post #36
post #35

One thing I'm considering is getting my kid a laptop when they start asking for a smartphone. They'll be able to engage socially for the most part, but it won't have the "with you every moment of every day" problem. And instead of a device that's mainly geared towards consumption, they'll at least have tool that's designed to to empower its user. And it will run Linux! No kid of mine will grow up thinking proprietary…

If they turn out not to be a programmer, won't using Linux hurt them? Basically every other profession/industry either use windows-only software, or have some kind of policy to use windows (microsoft intune, etc...)

When I was in school there was a lot of fear about not using Microsoft in public schools (Windows, Office, etc.) because of not preparing students for office jobs. Nowadays most schools use Chromebooks or iPads. And plenty of jobs use Google Suite, Apple, and non-Microsoft platforms too. Maybe they won't be using a GNU/Linux software suite as often, but the world is not all on one platform anymore.
Post reply on HN