Live data from Hacker News

Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

today.ucsd.edu

81–90 of 132 posts

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#81
post #78
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, all your eating happens in that 10 hour window. You fast for at least 14 hours per day. Easy enough if you eat an early dinner and don't snack after.

Is the position of that window relevant? So, I sleep 9h, which means, I'm awake 15h. If I don't eat 2,5h before and after sleeping, would this be enough?

[deleted]

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#82

Really enjoying IF and it's had enormous benefits for me. The doc basically said my latest bloods are outstanding, way, way down from the serious telling-off I got 6 months ago. I'm not using someone else's schedule, just listening to my body and pushing boundaries as hard as my fitness will allow. But there are mental "downsides" to reckon with. It's not grumpiness, but rather a "predatory" state. Not quite aggressi…

I know this feeling well. This is a false sense of sharpness caused by undereating. You dont feel hungry or tired, just energized, light and strong. I say false sense of sharpness, because you're actually not that alert. Yes, you can push yourself more, but your brain is in flight/fright mode and not thinking rationally.

Irrational thinking seems unlikely. When glucose deficit, the brain functions fine on ketones. It might be you're experiencing your brain running on ketones.

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#83
post #10

I am always unsure how this applies to someone with an irregular exercise schedule. If, when fasting (intermittent) my exercise is primarily cardio then I will continue fasting. However if it is resistance training, does getting some protein into my system as soon as possible take priority over fasting? Or is this less important than the immediate-protein-shake crowd suggests? Should I try to pull the window forward…

This is a very common question

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UF0AkfJqq2s

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#84
post #51
post #2

> “It’s not a pill, but a healthy habit that can significantly reduce these three risks of disease without any adverse side effects.” This is probably the case for a lot of health issues. But we always want a pill that will fix the issues while allowing us not to change our habits.

I remember reading that the reason that many doctors prescribe pills over a lifestyle change is that it is significantly easier to gain compliance. I can imagine it's kind of like being a parent or manager. After advising perfect behavior and rarely getting it, you give up and settle for easy, less perfect but achievable advice.

> doctors prescribe pills over a lifestyle change

does doctors prescribing lifestyle change have any noticeable effects though. I assume everyone already knows they need to 'eat better and exercise'. I am not convinced that doctor telling them this will finally make it sink in for anyone.

Also, most doctors have layman level understanding of nutrition and excercise and many of them are not in best shape themselves.

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#85
I've been trying to do this for years but I like my coffee with cream and sugar. I've tried various sugar/cream alternatives over the years but nothing really stuck. With coffee+lite cream + sugar I fast about 15 hrs a day. Am I getting any benefits at all?

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#86

Really enjoying IF and it's had enormous benefits for me. The doc basically said my latest bloods are outstanding, way, way down from the serious telling-off I got 6 months ago. I'm not using someone else's schedule, just listening to my body and pushing boundaries as hard as my fitness will allow. But there are mental "downsides" to reckon with. It's not grumpiness, but rather a "predatory" state. Not quite aggressi…

> The doc basically said my latest bloods are outstanding

What was the change in blood reports?

I am surprised somone can simply reverse their 'serious' metabolic disease state in mere 6 months.

Then what would be the point of living a healthy lifestyle everyday if you can simply 'get healthy' in a matter of months when you need it.

I've wondered about this for a while. My friends don't give a shit about health and barely do any physical activity. They can get to 'outstanding' equivalent level in 6 months at the time of their choosing? That doesn't seem fair,lol.

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#87

Really enjoying IF and it's had enormous benefits for me. The doc basically said my latest bloods are outstanding, way, way down from the serious telling-off I got 6 months ago. I'm not using someone else's schedule, just listening to my body and pushing boundaries as hard as my fitness will allow. But there are mental "downsides" to reckon with. It's not grumpiness, but rather a "predatory" state. Not quite aggressi…

I find macro timing/restriction to be better in combating "hangryness", meals before 10am and after 4pm are protein and carb heavy and anything in between is higher protien and low or near zero carb. I used to 16:8 and 18:6 IF but Id just be too moody.

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#88

Really enjoying IF and it's had enormous benefits for me. The doc basically said my latest bloods are outstanding, way, way down from the serious telling-off I got 6 months ago. I'm not using someone else's schedule, just listening to my body and pushing boundaries as hard as my fitness will allow. But there are mental "downsides" to reckon with. It's not grumpiness, but rather a "predatory" state. Not quite aggressi…

yes, I think it happens so you (we) can go hunting or harvesting or something, I can usually refocus that into cooking

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#89
To me, a 10-hr window (eg 8am-6pm) doesn’t seem restrictive or even mildly inconvenient (definitely not enough to classify as IF), so maybe the insight here is that people regularly eat across all their waking hours - and not doing that is better.

Re: Study: Time-Restricted Eating Improves Cardiovascular Health for Firefighters

#90

I've been trying to do this for years but I like my coffee with cream and sugar. I've tried various sugar/cream alternatives over the years but nothing really stuck. With coffee+lite cream + sugar I fast about 15 hrs a day. Am I getting any benefits at all?

I am the same way, except I just cream. Every time I have come across a discussion on this topic of having cream in your coffee while trying IF, the anecdata consensus is that any calories at all break your fast, so you are no longer fasting if you consume a small amount of cream/sugar.

Having said that, I still do 18/6 IF with cream in my coffee and in my personal experience I still feel great and have had many positive benefits from continuing IF.

Post reply on HN