Live data from Hacker News

Why are so many adults acting just like children?

aeon.co

41–50 of 140 posts

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#41

This article is full of such strange implied absolutisms and "just-so" stories. The silliest and most striking one is probably "Japanese women invented and pioneered emoji". As far as I know the :) symbol was first used by an American man, and there was no specific gendered usage of emoji afterwards.

Emoji and emoticons are not the same.

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#42

I gave up after a paragraph or two. It looked like it was going to moan about people trying to have fun and do some self care. I don’t have time for that. Over time, I’ve come to see many “senior” or “success” behaviours as refined versions of childhood ones. Political sniping, business competitiveness, standard hierarchical power dynamics, etc. These are all “playground tactics” but grown up. I don’t see (many) “suc…

I wouldn't say I liked the article, but it did have some nuance to it and ended with mostly an opposite conclusion:

"The seemingly extreme ways in which adults now play, from Zillennial runway models dressing like kindergarteners, to ‘cuddle parties’, to grownups who choose to marry at Disney resorts – all of it, and more to come – is a reaction to the extreme times in which we find ourselves living. The entire planet may be experiencing its own lost decades now – young and old are suffering. But, as the Japanese experience shows us, embracing our inner child isn’t necessarily a denial of reality. It can pave the way to an entirely new one. The Great Regression isn’t really a regression at all. It’s a sign of resilience in the face of profound adversity. When a child is born, it’s impossible to predict what they might become. Who can say what will emerge from our second childhoods?"

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#43

I don't even understand why do people become adult in the first place. Sure, your body changes and you begin to understand some more complex things you previously couldn't (and that's fun), but why change anything else? Why be boring and take bullshit seriously?

What bullshit are you referring to? I don't think there is a requirement to be boring but there certainly is a requirement to bring food on the table and cooperate with other individuals.

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#44

This article is full of such strange implied absolutisms and "just-so" stories. The silliest and most striking one is probably "Japanese women invented and pioneered emoji". As far as I know the :) symbol was first used by an American man, and there was no specific gendered usage of emoji afterwards.

"emoji" is a Japanese term. They were invented by Japanese phone manufacturer DoCoMo, and popularized in the west when implemented by the iPhone.

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Axe throwing, IPAs, cosplay outfits? Learn to play golf and drink scotch in your smoking jacket like an adult .

You're telling me kids won't chase a tiny ball around a yard or convince each other to consume things that are gross?

They have way more fun doing it, though.

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#46
It depends on what we want from our adults. And if we feel like we can demand some sort of contribution.

We got to a point where we can get away with the majority of our population being self-centered and living, at least part of their time, in a fantasy world as en escape from getting their life in order.

As the article claims it can be "nourishing", but nourishing for what. If you need parents, builders, engineers, philosiphers it won't make that out of them.

(im aware at least a bunch of the people who engage in this behaviour are actually contributing massively and this is their way of blowing off steam)

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#48
The most childish thing is trying to be an adult with absent understanding of why. Horrifying are the people who have kids just to keep up with the Jonses.

The parts I see actually worthy of concern of childishness are disregard for how things work and what it takes to achieve them. Relatedly there is a third issue of dependence but it has too many other non-attitude causes. These are my own admitted biases.

Childishness is a rather useless conflation of all. Humans are childish compared to great apes. Curiosity and tinkering are also childish but they have brought us the furthest forward.

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#49
Delayed Adulthood; there's no real reason to grow up any more, because young have all the rights but none of the responsibilities of their parents.

https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11-008-x/2007004/10311-e...

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/extended-adolesce...

https://archive.ph/OMwyL

Re: Why are so many adults acting just like children?

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Further down: > But as the legendary Midcentury Modern designer Charles Eames put it, ‘toys and games are the preludes to serious ideas.’ Grownups who play with Lego, dump fortunes into JPEGs of cartoon characters online or dress like overgrown toddlers force us to question long-held assumptions about adulthood and society as a whole.

I don't like the implication that those are somehow less worthy ways to spend one's time and money, or that the tendency towards those interests betrays some... divergent cognition or eccentricity. Pick any interest that you think is "proper" for an adult; the person who engages in it either enjoys it, in which case it's indistinguishable from any interest that doesn't meet that criterion, or they don't enjoy it, in…

It’s a generational article, for anyone of a certain age or older, explaining why what we see as “infantalization” serves a purpose and may yield very positive outcomes.
Post reply on HN