Live data from Hacker News

Path(v2) fly out menu already recreated and open sourced.

github.com

31–38 of 38 posts

Re: Path(v2) fly out menu already recreated and open sourced.

#31
post #10

Author needs to figure out a better way of doing screencapture. Using an image that might _actually_ induce seizures isn't a very good first impression.

Why does he need to make a good impression? look at the code and make your determination - build it and make a pull request with your improved video. This is the spirit of Github: he may be an awesome coder but weak in video production - fork and collaborate.

You seem to be of the mindset that "Open Source" means "other people will be eager to contribute". That's not necessarily the case. If you want people to contribute, you need to give them a reason to do so. People like contributing to high-quality projects. If the first impression of your project indicates a lack of quality, this will deter people from looking any further.

Re: Path(v2) fly out menu already recreated and open sourced.

#32
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Startup does something clever but simple; competition begins quickly. It's not the creator's fault that it's easy to reproduce and he did so in his free time. It's now free for everyone. Maybe the startup could clone his repo and keep part of their product updated by the community for free.

believe me: i deeply understand what's happening here; when i did del.icio.us there were hundreds of copies. because they did not understand the core decisions, they generally went down the wrong path. improving upon is cool. copying is lame.

I've felt this pain deeply as well, and a non-technology company. Founding one of the earliest successful coworking spaces, lots of other "shared offices" have popped up and even Regus has co-opted the term coworking and the physical attributes of a coworking space without considering the underlying decisions or core values that we've established.

See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult

Re: Path(v2) fly out menu already recreated and open sourced.

#33
post #10

Author needs to figure out a better way of doing screencapture. Using an image that might _actually_ induce seizures isn't a very good first impression.

I just posted a demo video on youtube. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vddaYMtETjo Done using iOS 5 simulator on iphone 4. I'm going to send a pull request to the author to include it in the README.

Also, here's a live, playable demo that you can interact with --

http://www.pieceable.com/view/bundle/p/3ed77/com.lunaapp.Awe...

Disclosure: this is running on my service.

Re: Path(v2) fly out menu already recreated and open sourced.

#34
post #20
post #14

Startup does something to differentiate themselves, is immediately copied. Lame.

If the only thing that differentiates you is a fancy fucking pop-up menu, you've already lost.

It's not just the menu. Is the whole thinking behind the use of it. Here's a nice interview of the founder telling how they wanted everything on one screen.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2iDjrW8NqJI

Re: Path(v2) fly out menu already recreated and open sourced.

#35
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Startup does something clever but simple; competition begins quickly. It's not the creator's fault that it's easy to reproduce and he did so in his free time. It's now free for everyone. Maybe the startup could clone his repo and keep part of their product updated by the community for free.

believe me: i deeply understand what's happening here; when i did del.icio.us there were hundreds of copies. because they did not understand the core decisions, they generally went down the wrong path. improving upon is cool. copying is lame.

You nailed it. Did they change the constrained iOS UI for the better? Yes. Do they want to see their menu pop up in every new app? Maybe no. But they clearly resolved an issue that many people have had for long. And we are thankful to them for that matter. I will sure look upon this code to see if I can get some inspiration. Remember, some painter said: "Good Artists Borrow, Great Artists Steal"

Re: Path(v2) fly out menu already recreated and open sourced.

#38
post #10

Author needs to figure out a better way of doing screencapture. Using an image that might _actually_ induce seizures isn't a very good first impression.

I just posted a demo video on youtube. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vddaYMtETjo Done using iOS 5 simulator on iphone 4. I'm going to send a pull request to the author to include it in the README.

I'm levey, thanks for your youtube demo:)
Post reply on HN