Live data from Hacker News

The anatomy of an ML-powered stock picking engine

principiamundi.com

1–10 of 109 posts

Re: The anatomy of an ML-powered stock picking engine

#4
Nice writeup, thank you for sharing so openly!

The three things I always want to know from stock picking ML people:

1. Did you put your own money in it ?

2. How'd it go?

3. How well does your engine do vs a fixed stock allocation based on trend-statistics computed on the whole time window (i.e., compared to a fixed optimal portfolio computed with mean/std values you don't have access to, but which isn't allowed to change its choice. what's the regret if you are familiar with online learning)

Re: The anatomy of an ML-powered stock picking engine

#7
post #4

Nice writeup, thank you for sharing so openly! The three things I always want to know from stock picking ML people: 1. Did you put your own money in it ? 2. How'd it go? 3. How well does your engine do vs a fixed stock allocation based on trend-statistics computed on the whole time window (i.e., compared to a fixed optimal portfolio computed with mean/std values you don't have access to, but which isn't allowed to ch…

Thank you for appreciating the article; I tried to disclose all that I could!

1. Yes, I did put my own money in it (low 6 figures).

2. It went as described in the article - for the capital I allocated to Didact, I beat the market (SPY) by ~20% since inception.

3. If I understand your question correctly, this would be the equivalent of the payoff on an optimal lookback option (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lookback_option). I haven't actually done that analysis, but it sounds like a nice idea.

Re: The anatomy of an ML-powered stock picking engine

#8
post #6

If you have a tool that can generate great returns, then why fall back to a newsletter?

Great question.

If I beat the market by 20% (say SPY generated 0% for the year, very optimistic at this point), and I have allocated $100k to this, I make $20k before taxes.

That's less than minimum wage.

Meanwhile, allocators expect a track record of at least 3-5 years.

Ideally, if I have an asset, I'd like to extract as much revenue as I can.

Hope this makes sense.

Post reply on HN