Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do you still buy physical tech books like “Learn Rust” or “Learn Go”?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 184 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do you still buy physical tech books like “Learn Rust” or “Learn Go”?

#21
I still like physical books for the fact that I learned to study by doing a lot of highlighting and note taking. It's just a bit more of a pain in the ass to do all of that when you've just got a PDF.

You get what you pay for in a good book by a good author from a reputed publisher most of the time.

They're SO HEAVY, though, and since I live on the road my books are my heaviest possessions. I always end up giving them away when I'm done with them full of highlighted stuff which people actually seem to appreciate.

This is the last one I powered through which I recommend anyone writing go get a copy of:

https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/concurrency-in-go/97814...

Re: Ask HN: Do you still buy physical tech books like “Learn Rust” or “Learn Go”?

#22

Personally, no. I've completely switched to ebooks. That being said, I'm the author of an ebook about Rust and Security (Black Hat Rust[0]) that sold thousands of copies, and I've been asked a few times for a physical edition: some prefer to have the hardcopy version on the desk when studying and programming. [0] https://kerkour.com/black-hat-rust

As many misgivings about dead trees that anyone may have, they sure are the way better format if you're buying someone a gift.

Cool book by the way I put it on my list of things to check out!

Re: Ask HN: Do you still buy physical tech books like “Learn Rust” or “Learn Go”?

#24
Yes.

I read fiction as ebooks (basically exclusively since days of palm pilot and Treo, then kindle and phone and tablets), but far prefer physical books when learning a new topic including tech. Few reasons but I think it's at least partially because:

1. It's easier to mark or hold with my finger e.g. A table or reference or definition page, then return or glance at it as I progress next few pages of that topic. I find it hard to go back and forth in ebook,triply so on e-ink with slow refresh.

2. I cannot explain this but with ebook I don't get a sense of progression or framework relationship. I think with physical book my brain "maps" knowledge to something that's at beginning middle or end of book. And or it's keenly aware that this topot took two pagds thjs topic took 7 pages. Layout of tables and content and lists is firmer. Not sure how to explain it but I find that physical progression through the book solidifies it in my brain.

(I don't do much note taking or highlighting but I suppose it's good to have as an easy physical option. While I type all my work notes and my todos are electronic, I don't do really do electronic book annotation for whatever reason.)

Overall, it's at the point where existence of really good physical book may influence whether I dig into an optional technical / learning topic or not.

Re: Ask HN: Do you still buy physical tech books like “Learn Rust” or “Learn Go”?

#25
I have found ebooks (at least on my Kindle) make reading code very hard. Wraps code which is not a good look for a language like Python and not much code is shown on each page. Also I find that I can not flip back and forth when I need to check up on something

I can scan through a physical book by just flicking pages, the Kindle does not update fast enough

For non technical books, books that I will read in a linear manner, the Kindle is just fine

Post reply on HN