Live data from Hacker News

Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

pcmag.com

91–100 of 335 posts

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#91
Craigslist might work well in large metro area like SF, but when your state is carved up into numerous non-overlapping regions and you're 60 minutes away from the center of either one to your side - it's just a sad roulette to see if you have to drive an hour to pick something up. With a simple distance-from-zipcode search implementation Craigslist could still be useful.

Sadly I'm stuck with Facebook Marketplace for now (which has been amazing for distance searches).

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#92
post #41
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Facebook Marketplace has completely taken over in most parts of the US. It sucks.

Any idea about Boston? Boston Craigslist has seemed a bit stale, but I'm not on Facebook to see how that compares.

Boston CL is indeed very stale, FB is way more active. Young people (Boston has a lot of good stuff in some areas. Need random leftover shelves? A pile of screened loam? Secondhand office furniture? An unused China set from the 1960s? No problem. But good luck trying to buy and sell normal home goods with any efficiency there; it will clear much much faster on FB marketplace. Maybe even for a better price.

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#93

Rock Auto is another such site. Looks old but is so much more effective than modern sites for finding the right car parts. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

I love Rock Auto. The way they make it easy to see which warehouse your items are shipping from and choose other items from the same warehouse is super cool too.

Just ordered something from them earlier this week. They got my repeat business because the last time I ordered something from them it was effortless (other than their kinda poor UI lol) and the item arrived super fast. I guess the shipping was a bit pricy, but that's fine. They had the part and got it to me promptly, and charged a fair price for it. Works for me!

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#94

* I far, far, far prefer Craigslist interface to anything else in that space. It's clear and focused Its search engine too - I get things I search for in the area I search for. For me, Kijiji and Facebook marketplace are awful UI, awful distractions, and give me 10,000 "suggested" or "fuzzy searched" things in random order, suppressing things I'm actually looking for. And I've completely given up on eBay over last de…

Craigslist is basically unusable in my area if you're selling something. 90%+ of the people who respond to you will express interest, chat about the item, set up a time to meet, and then no-show and ghost you. I don't know what they're getting out of it. It's not worth the time for me to go through 5-6 of those people for everything I want to sell.

Maybe Facebook, etc., have this problem too, but I gave up on selling things locally. These days I just try to pass things on to friends and family.

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#95
post #5

* I far, far, far prefer Craigslist interface to anything else in that space. It's clear and focused Its search engine too - I get things I search for in the area I search for. For me, Kijiji and Facebook marketplace are awful UI, awful distractions, and give me 10,000 "suggested" or "fuzzy searched" things in random order, suppressing things I'm actually looking for. And I've completely given up on eBay over last de…

A local media company runs a "classifieds" on their online site. It dominates locally. Craigslist has been worthless for ages here because of it. However, Facebook Marketplace seems to be slowly gaining traction. Which I hate for all the reasons you mention. I dread the day it takes over :(

In fairness, the only valid complaint I've heard about Craigslist is that it diverted classified ad revenue away from reporters, destroying local newspapers, and then local elections.

With Craigslist, this always felt like an unintended consequence. With facebook, it seems like one of their top ten strategies for getting us to devolve into mineshaft dwelling mole people that live in the metaverse.

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#96

* I far, far, far prefer Craigslist interface to anything else in that space. It's clear and focused Its search engine too - I get things I search for in the area I search for. For me, Kijiji and Facebook marketplace are awful UI, awful distractions, and give me 10,000 "suggested" or "fuzzy searched" things in random order, suppressing things I'm actually looking for. And I've completely given up on eBay over last de…

Although unfortunately, it doesn't understand the fairly typical non-urban "yes, you found something that's less than 10 miles from me as the crow flies, but is about 80 miles away if I need to actually drive there because of the fact that my car can't cross a river/strait/lake on its own". Even after 25 years, that part can still do with improvement.

Isn't this what the map view is for?

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#97
It's odd that this article came out only a few months after CL did a semi-significant change in the way they display listings -- the "gallery view" now lays out the screen differently, and it's fairly broken on mobile, pushing the left menu in and out randomly as you scroll (iOS Firefox and Safari anyway).

FWIW, I still use CL quite a lot in the SF Bay area. The cars listings are full of spam and scams, probably double what they were 5 or 6 years ago. This, despite the fact that they started charging for cars/trucks listings.

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#98
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Related, so many sellers are now “pro” sellers like what happened to eBay. Keyword stuffing, prices that are comparable to sale prices of new, constant automated reposting, etc.

Right, which is great: because CL forces folks to say whether they're a private owner or a dealer you can filter for those properties . And not hidden and tucked away either: it's the absolutely very first top-most set of options on the search results page. See those three [all] [owner] [dealer] buttons? Click "owner". You're welcome.

I've always wondered: what is the mechanism keeping people honest about being owner vs dealer?

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#99
post #91

Craigslist might work well in large metro area like SF, but when your state is carved up into numerous non-overlapping regions and you're 60 minutes away from the center of either one to your side - it's just a sad roulette to see if you have to drive an hour to pick something up. With a simple distance-from-zipcode search implementation Craigslist could still be useful. Sadly I'm stuck with Facebook Marketplace for…

Its also annoying when its the opposite, if I want to search for a car in California, I just stick myself centrally in Frenso and click all the adjacent areas since you can get SF, Sac, LA, Vegas.

Re: Why Craigslist still looks the same after 25 years

#100
post #94

* I far, far, far prefer Craigslist interface to anything else in that space. It's clear and focused Its search engine too - I get things I search for in the area I search for. For me, Kijiji and Facebook marketplace are awful UI, awful distractions, and give me 10,000 "suggested" or "fuzzy searched" things in random order, suppressing things I'm actually looking for. And I've completely given up on eBay over last de…

Craigslist is basically unusable in my area if you're selling something. 90%+ of the people who respond to you will express interest, chat about the item, set up a time to meet, and then no-show and ghost you. I don't know what they're getting out of it. It's not worth the time for me to go through 5-6 of those people for everything I want to sell. Maybe Facebook, etc., have this problem too, but I gave up on selling…

I'm not trying to justify or validate this behavior, but in my own experience you basically want the ability to buy the item, but may change your mind. So you string a buyer along while you make up your mind.

(personally, I've found myself doing this and then having to stop because the seller isn't some big mega corp, but just some random other working class friend)

Post reply on HN