Objectively the candidate passed. But deep down I felt that passing the interview doesn't show me about what real life design problems that the candidate have faced before.
Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
1–10 of 16 posts
Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#2Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#3[deleted]
Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#4[deleted]
Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#5Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#6If it's an early career engineer (If it's senior+ then yeah you might expect more. Especially if it's around something the engineer has worked with before.
Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#7Do you see the irony? Asking a “leetcode” question expecting an “non-leetcode” answer. Canned questions deserve canned answers. That’s what interviews have devolve into.
You get what you measure. You want better experience and person, have a conversation not an interrogation.
Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#8If someone giving you a correct answer is concerning, just change the questions that you use. But it would be ridiculous to penalize people for preparing.
Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#9Depends on the level. If it's an early career engineer ( If it's senior+ then yeah you might expect more. Especially if it's around something the engineer has worked with before.
More than an exhaustive correct answer?
Re: Ask HN: Would you hire someone who memorizes the System Design Interview book?
#10> my colleague gave *a common question that was found in System Design interview*. The candidate seems to be able to give a *perfect answer* Do you see the irony? Asking a “leetcode” question expecting an “non-leetcode” answer. Canned questions deserve canned answers. That’s what interviews have devolve into. You get what you measure. You want better experience and person, have a conversation not an interrogation.
It's not a pride thing, I want to work with people who can think. Asking leetcode questions proves they don't bother.