Live data from Hacker News

Our attention span is being robbed

unstructed.tech

11–20 of 161 posts

Re: Our attention span is being robbed

#12

People said the same thing about TV (and before that, newspapers/radio). With any new technology, societies will overdo it when it's new and then eventually find some happy-medium. You're seeing this happen now with more awareness around social media overuse or digital detoxes being more in vogue. People are slowly finding their happy medium. Fear not, it's all a part of the natural course of things.

> Fear not, it's all a part of the natural course of things. i bet some said that too !

I think humans are far more adaptable than the doomers will have you believe. Even if that adaptation takes some time at a societal level.

We've seen this with several technologies in the past, especially communication technologies. (Do you remember the doomer-ism around phone calls and telephones?)

Re: Our attention span is being robbed

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Being on Hacker News isn't any better than those platforms. Well, marginally better, but the overall effects are the same. Infinity pools of content, plus avenues for engagement in the comment threads.

There's a night and day difference between this platform and recommendation engines like IG, FB or TikTok. And there's even a larger difference in effects. The only reason I keep HN is because of the amount of quality-content related to my tech career.

Those platforms are worse but I don’t believe HN is any better in quality, just quantity. It’s a web forum linking to online content, it holds the same pitfalls for addictive behavior.

Re: Our attention span is being robbed

#17

We know this already, but I wonder what the remedies are. My SO can barely watch a movie or tv show before she gets back to infinite scrolling socials, it's a disaster. 5 minutes is the most she can do. Going out with me or friends is the same, few minutes and she's back checking emails and socials. I decided to lead by example and delete all socials, even reddit or linkedin, but it's impossible.

My family has taken inspiration from Orthodox Jews. At sunset we take all our devices and put them in a cabinet, turned off. Nobody can even call us on the phone. We have a big fancy dinner with fancy silverware and invite people over. Nobody is allowed to have their devices turned on. Until sunset on Sunday we just hang out or do whatever we wanted to do anyway, just with zero screens.

We end up reading books, playing board games, and having a lot more conversations. We're much more likely to go to the park. We often don't know what time it is which is a nice feeling. We also take a lot of naps because we're staying up too late most of the week on our screens.

I've also found I'm super productive on Monday after our screen free time. We've been doing it for a couple months now and I really like it.

Re: Our attention span is being robbed

#19
Tragedy of the unmanaged commons, in this case the commons is human attention. If Facebook doesnt grab it then Twitter will. The incentives of a for-profit capitalist society lead to this.

Apple should simply charge for notifications, and share the revenue w the user!

Re: Our attention span is being robbed

#20

We know this already, but I wonder what the remedies are. My SO can barely watch a movie or tv show before she gets back to infinite scrolling socials, it's a disaster. 5 minutes is the most she can do. Going out with me or friends is the same, few minutes and she's back checking emails and socials. I decided to lead by example and delete all socials, even reddit or linkedin, but it's impossible.

Good on you for doing what's difficult. Not everyone can, as you may be discovering.
Post reply on HN