Live data from Hacker News

IE has 1% of market share ... on HN: "Show HN" aftermath

news.ycombinator.com

31–37 of 37 posts

Re: IE has 1% of market share ... on HN: "Show HN" aftermath

#32

I'm surprised that only 3.5% appear to be using 27" iMacs or 27" Apple displays. I thought they were pretty ubiquitous at startups now (though less popular than MBPs, of course).

I always imagined the Dell Ultrasharps were the defacto startup montior.

Re: IE has 1% of market share ... on HN: "Show HN" aftermath

#34
post #24
post #20

Your calculation of claimed percentage of robots is deeply flawed. Not only do web browsers aggressively cache CSS files, but internet service providers also aggressively cache them. Though I'm a rare exception, my web browser is configured to ignore CSS completely, including both in-page styles and all additional loadable files. A configuration like this is very rare because it's difficult to do and the result often…

Same goes for JS files. There is only on page that I'm serving. I also know that there is 10% of visits are returning "customers". So there should be around 90 css/js files served per 100 html serves but it's not. Few minutes after releasing the app on HN I saw a swarm of "...bot" user-agents in my logs and lots of 405 errors also for the "...bot" user-agents. That made me think that the disproportion might be cause…

After looking carefully at the image you linked to, the first 405 seems to show your web server is configured to disallow HEAD requests (and probably others). The failed HEAD requests by "bot" User-Agents (along with what looks like some bots using forged User-Agents) is interesting since a HEAD request, if successful, does not actually load the page data and should not count in your page load stats. In other words, the bug is in the counting of pages loaded.

The tough questions is, why are you getting hammered by bots?

Re: IE has 1% of market share ... on HN: "Show HN" aftermath

#35
I had a similar amount of traffic from 2 HN posts. My IE percentage was 3.12% and chrome was 55.08% - pretty close to your numbers. Obviously, HN's browser stats will be way different than the general population, still very interestng. My analysis: http://onepix.me/blogs/10-HN-Traffic-Analysis-2-Posts-1-Week

Re: IE has 1% of market share ... on HN: "Show HN" aftermath

#36
post #34
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same goes for JS files. There is only on page that I'm serving. I also know that there is 10% of visits are returning "customers". So there should be around 90 css/js files served per 100 html serves but it's not. Few minutes after releasing the app on HN I saw a swarm of "...bot" user-agents in my logs and lots of 405 errors also for the "...bot" user-agents. That made me think that the disproportion might be cause…

After looking carefully at the image you linked to, the first 405 seems to show your web server is configured to disallow HEAD requests (and probably others). The failed HEAD requests by " bot " User-Agents (along with what looks like some bots using forged User-Agents) is interesting since a HEAD request, if successful, does not actually load the page data and should not count in your page load stats. In other words…

I'm not sure. It seems that the route is:

  HN -> Twitter -> A swarm of bots sitting on Twitter
When I re-posted my app on Sunday to get extra stats I saw the same thing. The Terminator Judgment Day happened but just on Twitter.
Post reply on HN