Live data from Hacker News

Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

windowscentral.com

1–10 of 27 posts

Re: Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

#2
"From December 2008 to October 2014, he led the team responsible for the redesign of the software user experience of Surface and Windows. Windows 10 was released in July 2015"

Ah, the guy that brought us touch-friendly tiles. On desktop. He makes good points, though.

Re: Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

#4
I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11. Once W10 support has ended I'm moving full time to Linux. I've already started the transition so I'll be more than ready when the time comes. Unnecessary changes with no benefit just show a lack of respect for the consumer and a level of arrogance I thought had been extinguished in Microsoft after the Windows 8 debacle. Clearly it hasn't.

Re: Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

#5
post #4

I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11. Once W10 support has ended I'm moving full time to Linux. I've already started the transition so I'll be more than ready when the time comes. Unnecessary changes with no benefit just show a lack of respect for the consumer and a level of arrogance I thought had been extinguished in Microsoft after the Windows 8 debacle. Clearly it hasn't.

> I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11

Interestingly, on both my laptops (2013 MBP and a 2015 Lenovo gaming laptop) Windows says that they "don't meet minimum requirements to install Windows 11". They're perfectly reasonable machines and Windows 10 runs smooth as butter on both of them, since when did Microsoft got so picky? Anyway, I'm sort of glad, because if the machines were eliglble for the Windows 11 upgrade, I'm sure MS would just go for it one night without my permission.

Re: Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

#6
post #4

I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11. Once W10 support has ended I'm moving full time to Linux. I've already started the transition so I'll be more than ready when the time comes. Unnecessary changes with no benefit just show a lack of respect for the consumer and a level of arrogance I thought had been extinguished in Microsoft after the Windows 8 debacle. Clearly it hasn't.

I wonder which Linux DE environment you will be using, KDE? I find Gnome's changes to be more unnecessary than Windows, e.g. Gnome 42 defaults to overview on login.

Overall, I find Gnome to at least be more consistent than Windows and no adverts in the activities/applications menus are of course appreciated. However, every major release tends to force the user to relearn certain how to use your desktop principals.

Re: Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

#7
post #4

I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11. Once W10 support has ended I'm moving full time to Linux. I've already started the transition so I'll be more than ready when the time comes. Unnecessary changes with no benefit just show a lack of respect for the consumer and a level of arrogance I thought had been extinguished in Microsoft after the Windows 8 debacle. Clearly it hasn't.

I keep reading such posts since Windows XP was released....

Re: Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

#9
post #5
post #4

I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11. Once W10 support has ended I'm moving full time to Linux. I've already started the transition so I'll be more than ready when the time comes. Unnecessary changes with no benefit just show a lack of respect for the consumer and a level of arrogance I thought had been extinguished in Microsoft after the Windows 8 debacle. Clearly it hasn't.

> I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11 Interestingly, on both my laptops (2013 MBP and a 2015 Lenovo gaming laptop) Windows says that they "don't meet minimum requirements to install Windows 11". They're perfectly reasonable machines and Windows 10 runs smooth as butter on both of them, since when did Microsoft got so picky? Anyway, I'm sort of glad, because if the machines were eliglble for the Windows 11 upgrade, I…

Probably missing the TPM.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trusted_Platform_Module

Re: Former Microsoft director of user experience trashes Windows 11 Start menu

#10
post #4

I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11. Once W10 support has ended I'm moving full time to Linux. I've already started the transition so I'll be more than ready when the time comes. Unnecessary changes with no benefit just show a lack of respect for the consumer and a level of arrogance I thought had been extinguished in Microsoft after the Windows 8 debacle. Clearly it hasn't.

>I won't be "upgrading" to Windows 11. Once W10 support has ended I'm moving full time to Linux.

I've been hearing people make this vow for decades now, but they almost never follow through.

>a level of arrogance I thought had been extinguished in Microsoft after the Windows 8 debacle. Clearly it hasn't.

Microsoft has always been arrogant; this is nothing new.

Post reply on HN