Live data from Hacker News

Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

twitter.com

201–210 of 266 posts

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#201
post #159
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From what I've heard about working conditions at EA, that's quite the indictment of Amazon!

EA has pretty good working conditions for SWEs.

They were notorious for having extremely bad working conditions. While they've supposedly made an effort to improve them, their notoriety won't go away quiet as fast

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#202

Surely this will be the Rubicon for FTC to take a serious look at the gaming industry, assuming this actually gets announced?

Consolidation doesn't equal monopoly. A monopoly is defined as "the exclusive possession or control of the supply of or trade in a commodity or service" - As long as indie game studios exist, the FTC will pay the gaming industry no mind. As long as games, as a commodity, can be created out of "thin air" (code), the FTC will pay the gaming industry no mind. Huge companies buying every major studio is definitely a "dic…

I'm not an expert on the law on this subject (or any subject lol), but I wonder how much a strict definition of the word "monopoly" actually matters? I would assume that the important thing is for the FTC to take action against businesses/practices that harm consumers, rather than focusing on the narrow definition of a single word.

Also, where did you get that definition of "monopoly" you quoted? There are a lot of definitions of that word flying around the internet, so I'm curious if you got that from like the FTC's website or something? I'm wondering because back when antitrust law was created, the issue at the time was railroad companies monopolizing transportation; however, what you're saying about indie games could also be said about transport: trains are not a monopoly, and they never could be as long as horses still exist!

> As long as games, as a commodity, can be created out of "thin air" (code)

Games are not created out of "thin air", they're created through very expensive labor, which is not only programming.

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#203

All ea games past and present require prime sub, but on the other hand a mass effect TV series would be nice if they don't fuck it up

> a mass effect TV series would be nice if they don't fuck it up After what they did to Halo I'm not holding my breath.

well quite, hence the bit at the end :D

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#204

Surely this will be the Rubicon for FTC to take a serious look at the gaming industry, assuming this actually gets announced?

No one can making any money except platform holders. 30% commissions are egregious. These aquisitions are just the side effect. We need a commission cap on all platforms that do over $1billion in annual sales. The Apple vs Epic trial revealed 80% margins for Apple on the App Store: https://9to5mac.com/2021/05/01/apple-runs-app-store-with-78-... A cap of 10-15% should do it.

I don't think a cap is the right solution. Better would be regulations, controls, etc to enable competition for marketplaces (at least for those of a certain size)

Like on iOS, if there was actual competition for app stores, Apple would face pressure from a competitive market to reduce their commission percentage. Developers will not want to put their apps/games on Apple's store if they continue to charge outrages fees, and they have alternative, realistic distribution options.

However, I don't know what regulation would look like there. Even if Apple is forced to allow third-party stores, it could still end up like the browser wars, where one company manages to secure a monopoly anyways. If we can't even fix the browser situation, I don't have high hopes for the appstore market.

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#205

All ea games past and present require prime sub, but on the other hand a mass effect TV series would be nice if they don't fuck it up

They couldn’t even stop from fucking up the games. Plus has Amazon studios released anything good?

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#206

Surely this will be the Rubicon for FTC to take a serious look at the gaming industry, assuming this actually gets announced?

Consolidation doesn't equal monopoly. A monopoly is defined as "the exclusive possession or control of the supply of or trade in a commodity or service" - As long as indie game studios exist, the FTC will pay the gaming industry no mind. As long as games, as a commodity, can be created out of "thin air" (code), the FTC will pay the gaming industry no mind. Huge companies buying every major studio is definitely a "dic…

FTC has more powers than investigating monopolies. It can investigate and sanction both unfair competition between businesses and deceptive, anti consumer practices. And there is a lot of practices in gaming industry that could potentially be investigated (console exclusives, lootboxes, platform commissions, etc).

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#207
post #205

All ea games past and present require prime sub, but on the other hand a mass effect TV series would be nice if they don't fuck it up

They couldn’t even stop from fucking up the games. Plus has Amazon studios released anything good?

Fair, and I'm not sure about anything they've made themselves, but some stuff they've published is ok, perhaps they can get a qualified professional to do it

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#208
post #159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

EA has pretty good working conditions for SWEs.

They were notorious for having extremely bad working conditions. While they've supposedly made an effort to improve them, their notoriety won't go away quiet as fast

Correct, with an emphasis on “were”. Things are different now.

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#209

All ea games past and present require prime sub, but on the other hand a mass effect TV series would be nice if they don't fuck it up

> a mass effect TV series would be nice if they don't fuck it up After what they did to Halo I'm not holding my breath.

What do you mean? Master Chief is best known for taking off his helmet at any and every opportunity, and for sleeping with Covenant spies while Cortana watches.

Edit: I also didn't expect them to use the people who did voice acting for the game, but it's bizarre to me that they decided to get Jen Taylor to voice Cortana but didn't decide to cast her as Halsey. Would have made more sense to just have the lady who played Halsey voice Cortana as well, since Halsey modeling Cortana after herself tells you a lot about her character and her overinflated opinion of herself.

Re: Amazon is not going to make a bid for Electronic Arts – sources

#210
post #205

All ea games past and present require prime sub, but on the other hand a mass effect TV series would be nice if they don't fuck it up

They couldn’t even stop from fucking up the games. Plus has Amazon studios released anything good?

Reacher maybe? But they somehow had the self-control to follow the book pretty closely for that one, which seems like a rarity for the sorts of people who get put in creative control of productions at Amazon, Netflix, etc.
Post reply on HN